Concrete Pipe and Products of Cal., Inc. Vs. Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern Cal.

Decided On : Jun-14-1993

Court : US Supreme Court

LAW: the Due Process Clause, the Fifth Amendment, a Trust Agreement, the Due Process Clause, the Trust Agreement, the Trust Agreement, the Fifth Amendment, Title 29 U. S. C. § 1104(a)(1, the Due Process Clause, Title 9, the Due Process Clause, the Due Process Clause, section 4201, the Fifth Amendment, Section 4.07, the Pension Plan, the Pension Plan, the Pension Plan, Section 4.08, Article X, the Federal Constitution, the Trust Agreement, The Trust Agreement, the Trust Agreement, Article X

ORG: Concrete Pipe & Products of Cal., Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern Cal., Syllabus, CONCRETE PIPE & PRODUCTS OF CALIFORNIA, INC., THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS, THE NINTH CIRCUIT No, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, Concrete Pipe and Products of, Concrete Pipe, the District Court, Plan, The Court of Appeals, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Congress, Court, Pp, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe's, Congress, Concrete Pipe, INC, Syllabus, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Court, Government, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Village of Euclid, Ambler Realty Co., Concrete Pipe, Plan, ERISA, Concrete Pipe's, ERISA, Usery, Turner Elkhorn Mining Co., Court, SCALIA, THOMAS, J., THOMAS, J., the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, the American Trucking Associations, Inc., Midwest Motor Express, the American Academy of Actuaries, the American Federation , Concrete Pipe and Products of, Concrete Pipe, Plan, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, the Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act, MPP AA, Concrete Pipe, the Takings Clause, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Labor, Congress of Industrial Organizations, the National Coordinating Committee for Multiemployer Plans, the Teamsters Pension Trust Fund of Philadelphia & Vicinity, INC, the Subcommittee on Oversight of the House Committee on Ways and Means, National Coordinating Committee for Multiemployer Plans, CFR, Washington Star Co., International Typographical Union Negotiated Pension Plan, ERISA, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Court, ERISA, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Congress, ERISA, the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation, INC, PBGC, Congress, Congress, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Multiemployer Study Required, Congress, ERISA, INC, Plan, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., Plan, INC, the Engineering Contractors Association, the Southern California Contractors Association, the District Court, the Labor Management Relations Act, Plan, Laborers, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe and Products Co., Inc., Cen-Vi-Ro, Concrete Pipe, Cen-Vi-Ro, Laborers, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Laborers, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Laborers, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe's, Employer, Concrete Pipe, Laborers, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Laborers, Concrete Pipe, Laborers, Concrete Pipe, Laborers, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Plan, Concrete Pipe, INC, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, the District Court, The District Court, Concrete Pipe's, Plan, Construction Laborers Pension Trust for, The District Court, the Ninth Circuit's, Shelter Framing Corp., Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Court, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Court, Congress, Concrete Pipe's, the District Court, Board of Trustees of Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California, Concrete Pipe and Products of California, Inc., Concrete Pipe, Court, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, Yahn &, McDonnell, Inc., Court, United Retail &, Wholesale Employees Teamsters Union Local, Yahn &, McDonnell, Inc., Plan, The District Court, Plan, Construction Laborers Pension Trust for Southern California, Concrete Pipe and Products, the Multi-Employer Pension Plan Amendments Act, Concrete Pipe and Products, i., INC, Amax Coal Co., Labor, American Trucking Associations, Inc., Midwest Motor Express, the Dispute Resolution Procedures, the Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act, Jerrico, Inc., INC, Jerrico, Inc., Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, INC, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, the Courts of Appeals, The Courts of Appeals, the Court of Appeals, the Third Circuit, Compare Keith Fulton & Sons, Inc., New England Teamsters, Pension Fund, Inc., Board of Trustees of Western Conference of Teamsters Pension Trust Fund, Thompson Bldg, Washington Star Co. v., International Typographical Union Negotiated Pension Plan, Textile Workers Pension Fund, Standard Dye & Finishing Co., Lindsay & Curr Co., Bakery, Confectionery & Tobacco Workers, Inc., Teamsters, Reply Brief, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, CFR §, the statute.14 , Virginia Pension Fund, United Retail & Wholesale Employees Teamsters Union Local No, Yahn & McDonnell, Court, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, INC, United States Gypsum Co., Fed, INC, THOMAS, INC, Concrete Pipe, Plan, the House Committee on Education, Labor, House, Congress, INC, the Senate Committee on Labor, Committee Print, Court, Congress, J. DeBartolo Corp., Florida Gulf Coast Building & Construction Trades Council, Congress, Court, Benson, Congress, Congress, INC, Congress, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, District Court, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, the District Court, the Court of Appeals, the District Court's, Fed, CONCRETE PIPE & PRODUCTS OF CAL., INC, Concrete Pipe's, United Retail &, Wholesale Employees Teamsters Union Local No, Yahn &, McDonnell, Inc., Seitz, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Reply Brief, INC, Casablanca Industries, Inc., ERISA, Fulton &, New England Teamsters, Committee Print, The Senate Committee Report, Senate] Committee, Labor, INC, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, the MPP AA, Plan, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe's, Usery, Turner Elkhorn Mining Co., Court, Skrupa, Wabash R. Co., Baltimore &, Ohio R. Co., Home Bldg, Blaisdell, Louisville &, Nashville R. Co., Mottley, Preston Co., Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, INC, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Plan, MPP AA, Association, Associations, Trustee, Contributions, Individual Employers, INC, Laborers, Laborer's Craft Master Labor Agreement, the "Southern California Master Labor Agreements, Concrete, Individual Employers, Local Union, Laborers', Craft Master Labor Agreement, the Pension Trust, ERISA, Contractors, the Southern California Master Labor Agreements, LIABILITY, UNION, Concrete Pipe's, the Contract Clause of Art, United States Trust Co., the MPP AA to, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe's, the Trust Agreement, Concrete Pipe, INC, Concrete Pipe, Plan, the Pension Trust, the Pension Trust, Concrete Pipe, Congress, Congress, Congress, first written.27 Following Connolly, Takings Clause, Concrete Pipe's, South Carolina Coastal Council, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, INC, Concrete Pipe's, Midwest Motor Express, Congress, Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Due Process Clause, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe & Products Co., Inc., Cen-Vi-Ro, Concrete Pipe, Oral Arg, Concrete Pipe, Village of Euclid, Ambler Realty Co., Concrete Pipe's, Concrete Pipe, Cen-Vi-Ro, Plan, FHA, The Darlington, Inc., CONCRETE PIPE & PRODUCTS OF CAL., INC, Usery, Turner Elkhorn Mining Co., ERISA, Concrete Pipe, Court, Concrete Pipe's, ERISA, ERISA, Concrete Pipe, Plan, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Concrete Pipe, Laborers', Craft Master Labor Agreement

GPE: U.S., Pp, Pp, Pp, Hearings, Shafter, California, the United States, California, Id., Monroeville, Ohio, District of Columbia, §, Harlan, United States, IV, United States, United States, New Jersey, New York City, the United States, Id.

DATE: 1993, 1992, December 1, 1992-Decided, June 14, 1993, 1980, 1974, 1391, 1401, § 1401(a)(3)(B, 16, 28, 1962, 1974, 1980, 1208, 1984, 1986, 10 essentially continuous years, each year, 50 (1979, 1991, 1983, 1974, 1974, 1306, 1978, 1976 ed., the five preceding years, 5-year, 1364, the next five years, 467 U. S., 475 U. S., 1978, July 1, 1978, 1978, 475 U. S., September 26, 1980, April 29, 1980, 1976 ed., 1053, 1391, 1242, § 1391, 5-year, the years, 1405, 1962, 75, 1947, 1976, 1978, 3-year, June 30, 1981, year, 1977, 1977, 1978, 1979, June 30, June 30, 15) days, 76, August 1979, October 1979, the spring of 1981, November 30, 1981, 1978, November 1981, January 1982, 89-94, February 1981, August 1979, September 26, 1980, 1502, 1983, 1984, 1461(e)(2)(a, CV-82-5184-HLH, July 5, 1989, June 27, 1991, 1401, 1987, 1986, 1981, 8, 1980, 1982, 1972, 1982, 1927, 1980, 446 U. S., 58, 1975, 446 U. S., 446 U. S., 1381-1399, 1405, 446 U. S., Fourth, Ninth, 1137, 1140-1143, 1396, 1403-1404, 1984, 1054, 1985, 10, 1502, 1511, 1984, 1984, 1992, 1983, 1984, 1986, 1381-1399, 1405, 1970, 1948, 1986, 1976, 1886, 421 U. S., 58, 1980, 4203, 1980, 4201, 4219, 4221, 104(2, Sept. 26, 1980, 1239, 4201, 1405, annual, the period of years, 1076, 1980, 20-21, 1980, 1988, 1932, 1961, 1804, today, today, a plan year, 1242, 1082, 1932, § 1401(a)(3)(B, 1990, 1082, 1974, 1973, 1974, 1137, 1143, CA1 1985, 1976, 1963, 1955, 1947, 1940, 1935, 1934, 1911, 1948, 1938, 1933, 467 U. S., only 31/2 years, 1962, 1962, 1977-1980, 1977-1980."24, 80-81, 32, 1977-1980, 1977-1980, 81-82, 467 U. S., 1977, 475 U. S., 475 U. S., today, 1003, 1015, 1992, this analysis years ago, 1978, 1987, 475 U. S., 1926, 1915, 475 U. S., 1958, 1364, 1976 ed., 475 U. S., 1977-1980, 82

CARDINAL: 91-904, 1, 1401(a)(3)(A, 2, 1, 616, 616, 1401(a)(3)(A, 621-631, 1393(c, 631, 2, 636, 3, 604, 604, 211, 223, three, 384, 641, 936, 576, 647, 649, 605 , 96, 94, 211, one, more than one, 606, 606, one, 28, hundreds, thousands, one, one, 607 , 29, 2530.210(c)(1, 582, 301, 304, 1002(34, 1002(7, 214, 608, 721, 215, 216, 609, 217, 725, 725.2, 2, 1082(c)(9, 610, 610, 1393(a)(1).4, 1391(b, 1301(a)(10)(A, 1399(b)(1, 1, 2, 1383(a).5 4, 7, 7, 1399(b)(2, 1401(a)(1, Two, 3)(B, 1401(b)(2, three, 612, 612, 6, half, half, at least sixty, 60, 6, fifteen, two, 90, 614, 614, two, 216, 400, 406, 8, 705, 198, 615, 416, 89-55854, 431, 936, 576, two, 1992).10, 735, 115, 787, 128, 9, 416, 10, 616, 616, 1, 139, 302(c)(5, 302(c)(5, 329, 1132(a)(2, 617 , 9, 168, 61, 195, 273, 510, 522, one, 238, 242, 618, 618, 60, 532, 61, 243, 2, 248, 245, 247, 9, 250, 247, 247, 1401(a)(1, 620, 247, 9, 1, 29, 29, 1401(a)(3)(A, 12, 250, 13, 762, 749, 729, 725, 843, 855, 621, 17, 10, 11, 29, 2641.4(a)(1, three, 83, 718, 628, 639, 787, 128, 138, 14, 1401(a)(3)(A, 358, 371, 395, 252, one, 623 , 624, one, 652, 655, 652, 626, 585, 617, 627 , 96, 1, 86, 29, 4221, 96, 1, 17, 93-406, 96, 94, 1401(a)(3)(A, 628, 628, 96, 1, 86, 2d, 635, 629 , 575, 62, 740, 749, 3, 433, 448, 2, 118, one, 630, 630, 575, 1401(a)(3)(A, one, two, 631, two, one, 2, 18, 213, 419, 632, more than one, 1082(c)(3, 633, one, 787, 146, 26, at least one, two, 433, 1401(a)(3)(A, 916, 85, 93, 93-383, 70, 93-807, 95, 635 , one, 762, 20, one, 625, 637, one, 487, 305, 729, 15-16, one, 28, 19, 21, 606, 22, 640, 640, 23, 23, 82, 34, 24, 33, 25, 7, 641, 733, 17, 13, 223, 218, one, 218, 2, 223, 224, three, 224, 225, one, 607, 644, 37, 130, 470, 497, 12, 224, 645 , 641, 26, 226, 29, 384, 394, 405, 226, 91, 646, 646, 15-16, 227, 226, 467, 721, 235, 227, 16, 227, 28, 29, one, 34

WORK_OF_ART: The Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act of, Plan, Multiemployer Pension Plan Termination Insurance Program, the Agreement, The Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendments Act, the Collective Bargaining Agreements, Plan, Brief for Petitioner 27, Brief for Respondent 2, Plan

PERCENT: 29 U. S. C. §§ 1381, an estimated 46%, 30%, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1301-1461, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1302(a, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1381(c)(2)-(4, up to 30 percent, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1362(b, 29 U. S. C. § 1461(e)(2)(A, 29 U. S. C. §, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1381,, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1241, 26 U. S. C. § 7701(a)(35, 29 U. S. C. , 29 U. S. C. §§ 1002(7, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1381-1399, 29 U. S. C. § 1401(a)(3)(A, 29 U. S. C. § 186(c)(5)(B, 29 U. S. C. § 1401(a)(3)(B, 504 U. S., 29 U. S. C. § 1401, 29 U. S. C. § 1002(21)([A, 29 U. S. C. § 1109, 409 U. S., 29 U. S. C. § 1399(b)(1, 29 U. S. C. § 1399(b)(2, 471 U. S., 235 U. S. App., 467 U. S., 467 U. S., 29 U. S. C. § 1401(b)(3, 29 U. S. C. § 1401(b)(3, 29 U. S. C. §, 29 U. S. C. §§ 1381-1399, 29 U. S. C. § 1393(a)(1, 26 U. S. C. § 7701(a)(35, 29 U. S. C. §, 46%, approximately 75%, 92.5%, up to 30%, 29 U. S. C. § 1362(b, 30%, 46%

NORP: §, amici, amici, Southeast, Multiemployer, d., §, d., Amici, d., d., d., Machinists, d., §, d., Amici, §

PERSON: Mter, e. g., J., J., J., J., Dennis R. Murphy, James M. Nelson, John S. Miller, Carol Connor Flowe, Jeffrey B. Cohen, Israel Goldowitz, Daniel R. Barney, Laurie T. Baulig, William H. Ewing, al, Alan Briefs, Lauren M. Bloom, Supp, Pub, R. A. Gray & Co., Connolly, Robert M. Weinberg, Laurence Gold, Thomas C. , G. Craig, Gerald M. Feder, David R. Levin, James D. Crawford, James J. Leyden, Thomas W Jennings, Kent Cprek, Robert A. Georgine, R. A. Gray & Co., Connolly, Supp, Connolly, P. L. 95-214, Connolly, Supp, 1002(8, Supp, Supp, Cen-Vi-Ro, Shafter, Shafter, Shafter, Vi-Ro Concrete Pipe , R. A. Gray & Co., App, App, Cert, LMRA, al, Village, Tumey, Marshall, Tumey, Marshall, Withrow, Larkin, Marshall, Jerrico, Marshall, W]e, Marshall, Trucking Indus, Republic Indus., e. g., Anderson , Liberty Lobby, Rule Civ, THOMAS, Lavine , W. Bailey, Powell, Withrow, Larkin, S. C. §, Pub, Edward, Crowell, Bedford, Story, Murray, Betsy, Marshall, C. J., DeBartolo, Shafter, Shafter, Rule Civ, J., H. R. Rep., Keith, Connolly, e. g., Ferguson, Williamson, Lee Optical, Carpenter, Norman , Loan Assn, Welch, Henry, Funkhouser, Turner Elkhorn, Turner Elkhorn, Individual Employer, N. Y. v., Connolly, Connolly, Connolly, Connolly, Connolly, Connolly, Connolly, Keystone Bituminous Coal Assn, DeBenedictis, al, Connolly, e. g., Hadacheck , Sebastian, Connolly, Connolly, Connolly, J., Turner Elkhorn, Connolly

ORDINAL: first, first, first, First, Second, Third, 96th, First, Second, first, second, third, first, first, first, first, first, First, Second, first, first, first, second, third, first, first, first, second, first, first, first, second, first, first, 96th, first, first, first, first, second, first, second, second, First, third, first, first, second

MONEY: 603 , 611 , 1.14, 29,337.71, 1.20, 49,913.04, 20,826.60, 613 , 268,168.81, 268,168.81, 190,465.57, 619 , 622 622, 625 , 634 634, 636 636, 638 638, 639 , 642 642, 643 Nothing, 647

EVENT: Plan, Plan, Plan, the 11, Plan, Plan, Plan

FAC: the MPP AA's, the MPP AA, Plan, the MPP AA

LOC: the Central States, the Southern California, the Central District, Southern California

PRODUCT: LMRA, App.213-214.18 While, Accord

TIME: each hour, hours

QUANTITY: 7,000 tons, 71 Geo