Marsh Vs. Ore. Natural Res. Counc.

Decided On : May-01-1989

Court : US Supreme Court

LAW: the Administrative Procedure Act, Page 490 U. S. 362 , Page 490 U. S. 367 , the Administrative Procedure Act, Page 490 U. S. 382 , the Freedom of Information Act, Title 5 U.S.C. § 706(2

ORG: Marsh, Ore. Natural Res, U.S. 360, U.S. Supreme Court, Marsh, Ore. Natural Res, U.S. 360, Oregon Natural Resources Council No, THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS, THE NINTH CIRCUIT, Syllabus, The Elk Creek Dam, The Army Corps of Engineers (Corps, Environmental Impact Statement, the Elk Creek, Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement No, FEISS, the Elk Creek Dam, the Lost Creek, Elk Creek Dams, FEISS, the Corps' Division Engineer, Congress, the District Court, the Elk Creek Dam, the National Environmental Policy Act, NEPA, Oregon Department of Fish and, ODFW, ODFW, the Lost Creek Dam, the Elk Creek Dam, SCS, FEISS, The District Court, Corps, The Court of Appeals, FEISS, ODFW, SCS, Page 490 U. S. 361 , The Court of Appeals', FEISS, Methow Valley Citizens Council, FEISS, NEPA, NEPA, Council on Environmental Quality, Corps, FEISS, Court, Supplemental Information Report, SIR, ODFW, ODFW, SIR, SCS, Court, Court, Methow Valley Citizens Council, the National Environmental Policy Act, NEPA, EIS, the Lost Creek Dam, the Applegate Dam, the Elk Creek Dam, Congress, the Army Corps of Engineers (Corps, The Lost Creek Dam, the Applegate Dam, the Elk Creek Dam, Corps, EIS, EIS, the Lost Creek Dam, the Elk Creek, the Elk Creek Dam, Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement No, Nation, FEISS, FEISS, the Elk Creek Dam, JTU, the Elk Creek Dam, the Lost Creek Dam, FEISS, the Lost Creek, Elk Creek Dams, FEISS, FEISS, FEISS, the Corps' Division Engineer, the Elk Creek Dam, the United States Congress, Congress, the Elk Creek Dam, Corps, NEPA, NEPA, NEPA, EIS, Corps, the Elk Creek Dam, the District Court, Corps, Oregon Department of Fish and, ODFW, ODFW, the United States Soil Conservation Service, SCS, FEISS, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65(a)(2, The Court of Appeals, the District Court, the Court of Appeals, FEISS, Methow Valley Citizens Council, the Court of Appeals, ODFW, SCS, ODFW, SCS, NEPA, NEPA, NEPA, NEPA, NEPA, Act, TVA, NEPA, NEPA, Council on Environmental Quality, CEQ, Sierra Club, EIS, Corps, NEPA, Page 490 U. S. 373 , EIS, EIS, NEPA, EIS, APA, Corps, FEISS, Corps, FEISS, ODFW, SCS, Corps, Sierra Club, Baltimore Gas & Electric Co., Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Corps, Corps, FEISS, Volpe, EIS, ODFW, ODFW, the Lost Creek Dam, SCS, FEISS, FEISS, Supplemental Information Report, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Elk Creek Lake Supplemental Information Report No, SIR, NEPA, EIS, SCS, FEISS, ODFW, SCS, FEISS, The Court of Appeals, ODFW, the Lost Creek Dam, the Elk Creek Dam, the Elk Creek Dam, ODFW, SIR, SIR, ODFW, ODFW, SIR, the Elk Creek Dam, SIR, Corps, the Court of Appeals, the Lost Creek Dam, the Applegate Dam, the Lost Creek Dam, Corps, the Lost Creek Dam, FEISS, Corps, Corps, ODFW, ODFW, Elk Creek Dam, ODFW, The Court of Appeals, SCS, the Elk Creek, FEISS, FEISS, ODFW, FEISS, SIR, SCS, FEISS, JTU, the Elk Creek Dam, SIR, SCS, Page 490 U. S. 385 , SCS, Corps, Corps, NEPA, SIR, Corps, the Court of Appeals, the Army Corps of Engineers, Klamath Counties, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Elk Creek Lake Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement No, Dec.1980, the Jackson Turbidity Unit, JTU, JTU, JTU, JTU, FEISS, the Elk Creek, Elk Creek, Elk Creek Dam, Rogue, Oregon Department of Fish, JTU, Elk Creek Dams, Third International Dictionary 2004, Inc., Washington Game Dept, Lost Creek Dam, Elk Creek, the Senate Appropriations Committee, Army, the Elk Creek Lake, the Oregon Natural Resources Council, the Oregon Guides and Packers Association, Inc., the Rogue River Guides Association, FOIA, NEPA, FOIA, NEPA, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure, NEPA, Congress, Federal Government, NEPA, the Implementation of Environmental Policy, L.J. 205, EIS, Senate, NEPA, Sierra Club, EIS, NEPA, the Federal Government, CFR, TVA, the Court of Appeals, NEPA, CEQ, CFR, EIS, EIS, CFR §, NRC, FERC, Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp., Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Northern Lines Merger Cases, NEPA, Federal, the National Register of Historic Places, Federal, State, CFR, §§ 706(2)(E, APA, APA, Volpe, § 701(a)(2, Courts of Appeals, the Court of Appeals, the Ninth Circuit, Sierra Club v. Froehlke, National Wildlife Federation, Monarch Chemical Works, Manasota-88, Inc., Corps of Engineers of United States Army, NEPA, SIR, EIS, EIS, EPA, CFR, SIR, ODFW, Lost Creek Dam, the Lost Creek Dam, SIR, FEISS, ODWF, Critique of Lost Creek Dam Fisheries, Lost Creek Dam Fisheries Evaluation, Rogue, Elk Creek Dam, Lost Creek Dam, Commission

DATE: 1989, 1989, 87-1704, January 9, 1989, May 1, 1989, 1971, 1980, 1985, 1969, 1980, 706(2)(a, 1974, 1979, 1980, 1489, 1969, 4321, 1930, 1961, 7-89, 1962, The following year, 1961, 1962, 1192-1193, 1977, 1981, annual, 1971, 1975, December, 1980, 1974, 1979, 1974, 1979, 1974, 1974, 38, 46, February 19, 1982, 53a, 58a, August, 1985, Aug. 15, 1985,, October, 1985, 1980, 1557, 1986, 1562, 1982, 1563-1565, 1567, 1567-1568, 1489, 1987, 1497, 1493-1494, 1496-1497, 1494-1496, 4321, 34 (1978, 1979, 1976, 1983, 1971, February 21, 1985, 1982, 1980, January 10, 1986, October, 1985, 1982, early winter, spring, spring, January, spring, 10a, 10a, July, August, December, those months, 10a, 1979, 1980, 1977, 11a, 1495, the early 1980's, 1970, 12a, 1974, 1979, 1974, 1979, 21-22, 1974, 1979, 1980, 12a, August 1, 1979, annual, normal years, summer, season, late July, October, the winter, late summer, early fall, 36, 1981, 1977, 1985, 1278, a later date, 1496, 1989, 18 (1976, 40416, 1969, 1987, 1164, 1972, May, 1987, 1987, 1017, 1024, 1980, 1442, 1463-1464, 1984, 1985, D.C. 54, 57, 1985, D.C. 329, 93, 1983, 1978, 1944, 1970, 1987, under § 706(2)(C, 1971, 1987, 1363, 1373, 1985, 782, 1983, CA1 1983, 1083, 1087-1088, 1979, CA7 1984, 1986, 1985, 1986, today, 1987, August 1985, last October and, November, this spring, spring, last winter, last October-November, previous years, August 15, 1985, 1979, 1980, 1979, 1980, 1489, 1501, 1987, September, October, spring, February-April, 11a, post-dam years, spring, spring, 5a

CARDINAL: 490, 490, three, 1, one-third, four, two, two, 1, 2, 5, two, 832, 363, 83, 852, 42, 1, 346, 49, 439, three, 566, 2d, 87, 203, 76, five, 2, three, 3, 1, one, 33, one to, one to three, 33-34, 6, 100, 17, 26, 8, 35, 27, 9, 99, 314, about one-third, four, 10, 1, three, 2, 3, 4, 11, 628, 690, 753, 761, three, 628, two, two, 832, 12, 832, 1500, 13, 14, 42, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 36, 20, 42, 4332(2)(C, 5, six, 21, 29, 2)(D, 22, 23, 401, two, two, 3a, 2, 7a, 25, 26, two, only one, 381, one, 9a, 4a, 29, 383, two, 30, 9a, 3a, 832, 33, no more than one to three, 18-19, 33, 1, 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 10, 20, 50, 21, 3, 4, 2, 5, 37, 6, 10, 20, 13, two, 433, 8, 35, 9, 99-82, 97, 10, four, 16, 5, 552, 12, 832, 5, 13, 2, 853, 42, 4332, 64, 247, 115, 40, 15, 468, 16, 1, 2, 40, 17, 40, 33, 230.11(b, 18, 621, 32, 740, 249, 772, 972, 975, 14, 231, 345, 720, 109, 19, 20, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8), 9, 10, 40, 1508.27, 21, 556, 557, 706(2)(F, 22, 5, 23, 816, 205, 769, 721, 716, 946, 948, 604, 745, 412, 417, 799, 687, 692, 764, 445, 449, 24, 25, 26, 33, 230.11(d, 109, 4a, 832, 29, 4a, 30, 112, 114

PERSON: Marsh, Robertson, J., STEVENS, Robertson, Robertson, H.R. Doc, Pub, Elk Creek, Fahrenheit, Cert, Pub, Robertson, Wallace, Robertson, Ante, Hill, Robertson, Andrus, Kleppe, Citizens, Preserve Overton Park, Josephine, Atiyeh, Webster, Puyallup Tribe, Kleppe, Jackson, Dole, Cuomo, Context, Citizens, Enos, Weinberger, Thomas, John R. Donaldson, Record, Doc, Wallace, S. B. Mathews, Record, Doc, L. Calvin, Admin, Record, Doc, Harry

EVENT: U.S. 360 CERTIORARI

GPE: Oregon, Oregon, Pp, Oregon, Basin, Elk Creek, Oregon, Oregon, the United States, Oregon, California, Portland District, Elk Creek, Oregon, Jackson, Del Norte, Siskiyou, California, Gold Beach, Oregon, Portland District, Elk Creek, Elk Creek, Elk Creek, Jersey City, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, Admin, Admin

LOC: Rogue River Basin, the Rogue River, the Rogue River Basin, the Rogue River Basin, the Rogue River, the Applegate River, the Rogue River, the Rogue River, the Rogue River, the Rogue River, the Rogue River Basin, the Rogue River, the Rogue River, the Rogue River, Rogue River, the Rogue River, Rogue River Basin, Rogue River, Crater Lake, the Pacific Ocean, the Rogue River, Rogue River, the Rogue River, Rogue River, Lost Creek, the Rogue River, Applegate River, Rogue River, Wild, Tennessee River, River

ORDINAL: second, first, second, second, second, second, first, second, first, second, second, second, first, second, second, first, second, first, second, second, first, second, first, second

WORK_OF_ART: the Cramer Memorandum, Cramer Memorandum, The Cramer Memorandum, Cramer Memorandum 3a, the Cramer Memorandum

FAC: Elk Creek, the Elk Creek, Lost Creek Dam, the Elk Creek, the Elk Creek, the Lost Creek Dam, Reply Brief, Preserve Overton Park, the Lost Creek Dam

QUANTITY: 238-foot, 132 square miles, 135-square-mile, 1,290 acres, 18-mile, 101,000 acre-feet, 26,000 acres, two degrees, 1,290 acres, only 0.6 degrees, 0.6 degree, 5,060 square mile, about 0.2 miles, 355,000 pounds, 71,000 pounds

MONEY: approximately $100 million, almost $5 million, 706, 24

NORP: F.Supp, d.

PERCENT: 442 U. S. 347 , 462 U. S., 401 U. S. 402 , 60-80%, 60-to-80 percent, between 30 and 40 percent, 76%, 32%, approximately 14 percent, 401 U. S. 402 , 475 U. S. 1055

PRODUCT: 706, Cole M. Rivers, F, 210, 767, Thone, Circuits