Skip to content

Semantic Analysis by spaCy

Commonwealth Edison Co. Vs. Montana

Decided On : Jul-02-1981

Court : US Supreme Court

Notice (8): Undefined index: topics [APP/View/Case/meta.ctp, line 36]
Warning (2): Invalid argument supplied for foreach() [APP/View/Case/meta.ctp, line 39]

LAW: the Montana Constitution, the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, the Due Process Clause, the Due Process Clause, Constitution, the Supremacy Clause, Section 32, the Sherman Act, the Supreme Law, Constitution, the Reclamation Act, Section 35, the Clean Air Act, The Clean Air Act, Constitution, Constitution, section 1

ORG: Commonwealth Edison Co., U.S. 609, U.S. Supreme Court, Commonwealth Edison Co., U.S. 609, Commonwealth Edison Co., THE SUPREME COURT, MONTANA, Syllabus, State, Commerce, the Montana Supreme Court, Commerce Clause, Thomas Colliery Co., State, State, the Complete Auto Transit , State, the Complete Auto Transit, State, State, State, State, the Mineral Lands Leasing Act, the Federal Government, Congress, Congress, State, Mid-Northern Oil Co. v. Walker, the Federal Government, Federal Government, the Powerplant and Industrial Fuel Use Act, Congress, Court, BURGER, C.J., BRENNAN, WHITE, REHNQUIST, WHITE, J., BLACKMUN, POWELL, STEVENS, Court, State, State, Commerce, Senate, Montana Legislative Council, the Montana Legislature, the Montana Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Court, Thomas Colliery Co., Oliver Iron Mining Co., Commerce Clause, Commerce Clause, Court, the Montana Supreme Court, the Commerce Clause, Heisler, the Complete Auto Transit , Ozark Pipe Line Corp., Monier, Court, Commerce Clause, Washington Apple Advertising Comm'n, Pike v. Bruce Church, Inc., Court, Complete Auto Transit, Inc., Mobil Oil Corp., Taxes, Complete Auto Transit, Inc., Commerce Clause, Commerce Clause, Calvert, State Tax Comm'n, Commerce Clause, Mobil Oil Corp., Taxes, Court, State, Court, Bureau of Revenue, Postal Telegraph, Cable Page 453 U. S. 617 Co., Heisler Court's, Commerce Clause, Commerce Clause, State, State, the Complete Auto Transit , the Montana Supreme Court, the Complete Auto Transit , Page 453 U. S. 618 , Court, Boston Stock Exchange, State Tax Comm'n, Court, State, Court, Heisler Court's, State, State, the Commerce Clause, State, Washington Apple Advertising Comm'n, Boston Stock Exchange, State Tax Comm'n, Court, Kansas Natural Gas Co., See Boston Stock Exchange, State Tax Comm'n, State, State, State, the Commerce Clause, State, State, the Complete Auto Transit, State, State, the Complete Auto Transit , State, State, State, State, the Complete Auto Transit , The Montana Supreme Court, Court, State, Delta Airlines, Inc., Ingels, Court, Alco Parking Corp., Magnano Co., Smith, St. Louis & S.W. R. Co., Nattin, the Commerce Clause, State, Ford Motor Co., Beauchamp, , Page 453 U. S. 624 , Colonial Pipeline Co., Traigle, Bureau of Revenue, Exxon Corp., Wisconsin Dept, Revenue, Japan Line, Ltd., POWELL, General Motors Corp., State, State, State, State, Western Union Telegraph Co., Postal Telegraph Cable Co., Adams, Page 453 U. S. 625 , State, J. C. Penney Co., General Motors Corp., State, State, State, State, J. C. Penney Co., the Complete Auto Transit , State, the Complete Auto Transit , State, the Complete Auto Transit , State, Western Live Stock v., Bureau of Revenue, National Geographic Society, California Board of Equalization, Standard Pressed Steel Co., Court, J. C. Penney Co., State, the Complete Auto Transit , General Motors Corp., State, State, State, State, Exxon Corp., Wisconsin Dept, Japan Line, Ltd., the Complete Auto Transit, Magnano Co., Court, Congress, Mobil Oil Corp., Taxes, Moorman Mfg, State, State, the Complete Auto Transit, State, Calvert, State, the Complete Auto Transit , the Mineral Lands Leasing Act, the Federal Coal Leasing Amendments Act, the Federal Government, Page 453 U. S. 630 , the Federal Government, the Federal Treasury, Commerce Clause, the Federal Treasury, the Federal Government, Congress, Court, Congress, Congress, Mid-Northern Oil Co. v. Walker, Congress, The House Report, the Federal Government, the Federal Government, J.S.App, Court, Mid-Northern Oil Co. v. Walker, Federal Government, the Mineral Lands Leasing Act, the Energy Policy and Conservation Act, Nation, the Powerplant and Industrial Fuel Use Act, Exxon Corp., Court, Page 453 U. S. 634 , Congress, Chicago & North Western Transp, Kalo Brick & Tile Co., Florida Lime & Avocado Growers, Inc., Paul, Rath Packing Co., Congress, Stat, Page 453 U. S. 635 , State, State, State, State, Congress, Senate, House, Senate, House, the Mineral Lands Leasing Act, the Joint Conference on Energy 1822,, Energy, Legislative History:, House, Congress, the Supreme Court, Congress, Commerce, Nations, Heisler Court, the Commerce Clause, Pike v. Bruce Church, Inc., Hellerstein, Constitutional Constraints on State and Local Taxation of Energy Resources, Yale L.J. 219, Harv, Court, East Ohio Gas Co., Tax Comm'n, State Tax Comm'n v. Interstate Natural Gas Co., Commerce Clause, State, State, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Western Live Stock v., Bureau of Revenue, State, the Montana Supreme Court, Court, Interstate Transit, Inc., Lindsey, , State, Ingels, State, Agric, State Taxation of Mineral Deposits and, U.S. Bureau of Census, State Government Tax Collections, the Complete Auto Transit , General Motors, J. C. Penney, National Geographic Society, California Board of Equalization, the Complete Auto Transit, Exxon Corp., Wisconsin Dept, Revenue, Mobil Oil Corp., Taxes, Japan Line, Ltd., National Geographic Society, California Board of Equalization, State, Magnano Co., Congress, Congress, Congress, the Mineral Lands Leasing Act, the United States Treasury, State, Treasury, State, the United States Treasury, the Federal Government's, Exxon, Court, the Robinson-Patman Act, WHITE, Court, Montana, the Federal Government, the Federal Government, State, Congress, Nation, Congress, the Executive Branch, the Commerce Clause Page 453 U. S. 638 , Congress, Court, Court, State, Court, Nation, Department of Energy, National Coal Assn, Coal Data, the Federal Government, State, the Subcommittee on Energy and Power of the House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce, J. Krutilla & A. Fisher, Krutilla, Nation, the Montana Legislature, State, Legislature, the Free Joint Conference Committees, Coal Taxation 1 (, Committees, Committees, State, State, Montana, State, Griffin & Shelton, Coal Severance Tax Policies, State, Oral Arg, Montana, State, the Federal Government, the Interstate and Foreign Commerce Committee, OPEC, State, R. Nehring & B. Zycher, Coal Development and Government Regulation, Church, State, Court, Bureau of Revenue, Complete Auto Transit, Inc., Simet & Lynn, Interstate Commerce Must Pay Its Way: The Demise of, Foreword, State Taxation, Court, Court, Commerce Clause, State, State, Court, Commerce Clause, Court, Court, Court, the Complete Auto Transit , Court, the Complete Auto Transit , State, Court, Thomas Colliery Co., Court, Court, Oral Arg, Court, the Commerce Clause, Court, Court, Western Live Stock, State, Exxon Corp., Wisconsin Dept, Revenue, Japan Line, Ltd., State, Postal Telegraph-Cable Co., Court, the Commerce Clause, State, Calvert, State, Court, Commerce Clause, State, Court, State, Court, Berwind-White Co., Raymond Motor Transportation, Inc., Court, the Complete Auto Transit, Harv, State, Yale L.J. 219, Hellerstein, Constitutional Constraints on State and Local Taxation of Energy Resources, Posner, State, Michelin Tire Corp., State, Commerce, Clause, State, State, Court, State, Congress, Congress, Court, solidarity, Nation, Krutilla, the Montana Legislature, Emphasis, State, Conflicting Federal, State, Local Interest Trends, State, Montana Subcommittee, the Montana Legislature , Dakotas, Subcommittee, the Montana Legislature, Legislative Committee, Coal Tax 4, The Montana Supreme Court, Oral Arg, Montana, State, State, State, State, Court, the Complete Auto Transit, State, U.S. 820, State, N.Y. Times, A10, State, Court, the Complete Auto Transit, J. C. Penney Co., General Motors Corp., Court, Fourteenth Amendment, Court, General Motors, Court, Court, Postal Telegraph-Cable Co., Court, Court, Court, State, Evansville-Vanderburgh Airport Authority Dist, Delta Airlines, Inc., Ingels, Court, the Montana Supreme Court, Court, State, the Free Joint Conference Committees, Coal Taxation 1 (, POWELL

GPE: Montana, Montana, U.S., Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, States, States, Montana, Montana, Montana, States, States, Montana, Montana, Mont., Montana, States, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Mont., Mont., Montana, Montana, Mont., Montana, Montana, Montana, U.S., Montana, States, States, Richmond, Washington, Washington, Michigan, Washington, Washington, Richmond, Montana, U.S., Montana, Montana, Mont., Montana, Montana, Montana, States, States, Montana, Maryland, Louisiana, Philadelphia, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, U.S., U.S., Montana, Montana, Montana, States, Montana, Philadelphia, New Jersey, Montana, U.S., Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Mont., States, Pittsburgh, Alaska, States, States, U.S., Los Angeles, Washington, U.S., Washington, Montana, Maryland, Louisiana, U.S., Virginia, Missouri, Wisconsin, Washington, Wisconsin, Inc., U.S., Washington, Wisconsin, Montana, Washington, U.S., Montana, Montana, Richmond, U.S., U.S., Los Angeles, U.S., U.S., U.S., U.S., Richmond, U.S., Michigan, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, the State of, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, States, the United States, the United States, Montana, Montana, pp, States, the United States, States, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Maryland, California, Montana, Western States, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, States, California, Massachusetts, States, States, U.S., California, Montana, Mont., Montana, Mont., Montana, Montana, U.S., U.S., States, Michigan, U.S., U.S., U.S., Los Angeles, Washington, Juris, Montana, U.S., Montana, Montana, States, the United States, the State of, Montana, States, Montana, Montana, Montana, States, Montana, Montana, United States, the United States, Montana, Hearings, Montana, States, pp, Montana, Montana, the Province of, Alberta, Canada, Alberta, Montana, Alberta, Alberta, Montana, Wyoming, Montana, North Dakota, Montana, North Dakota, Juris, Montana, Montana, Mont., Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, the United States, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, U.S., U.S., Maryland, Louisiana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, Montana, U.S., U.S., Maryland, Louisiana, U.S., U.S., Los Angeles, Richmond, Richmond, Michigan, Texas, Richmond, U.S., U.S., U.S., U.S., Maryland, Louisiana, U.S., Montana, Oklahoma, Montana, Montana, Wyoming, United States, Wyoming, Montana, the United States', Montana, Wyoming, States, Montana, Montana, North Dakota, Wyoming, valorem, North Dakota's, Montana, Wyoming, States, Wyoming, Montana, Montana, Montana, Mont., Montana, States, Washington, Alaska, Alaska, Montana, Wisconsin, Washington, Wisconsin, Wisconsin, Wisconsin, New York, Wisconsin, U.S., U.S., Richmond, Va., U.S., U.S., Montana, Mont., U.S., Washington

CARDINAL: 453, 453, 80, 453, 11, 1, 2, 615, 1, three-fourths, 5, 4, 11, 615, 847, 2, four, 3, 449, 4, 6, four, 430, two, 615, 855, 260, 251, 432, one, one, 430, 9, 10, 615, 856, 11, 12, 303, 435, 13, 451, 14, 15, 303, 377, 327, 447, 441, 16, 17, 18, 445, 437, 301, 327, 41, 437, 30, 181, 94, 90, 19, 20, 32, 41, 450, 30, 189, 30, 189, 32, 94-681, 17-18, 32, 35, 30, 191, 38-41, 32, 30, 189, 2(6, 89, 874, 42, 6201(6, one, 92, 3291, 42, 8301(b)(3, one, 96, 21, 42, 37, 92, 42, 8401(a)(1, 42, 93, 2, 777, 779, 787, 789, 794, 777, 1, 15-35-102(1, 2, 3, 3, 2, 4, 260, 5, 31, 249, 67, 232, 75, 953, 970, 6, 8, one, 615, 847, 856, 5, 970, 248, 9, 10, over 2.00, 12, 8, 615, 851, 12, 306, 598, 300, One, 20, 122, 122-130, 13, 6, 14, 430, 8, 15, 430, 16, 17, 18, 19, 35, 41, 450, 30, 191, 1, 32, 388, 43, 391, 30, 191, 20, 21, 437, 22, 42, 15, 2/1, 8, 14, 2d, 22, 96-1527, 1, 3-4, 3, 2/2, 525, 2/3, 96-1527, 1, 3, 2/4, 2/5, 2/6, 96-1527, 1, 3, 642, 7, three-fourths, 5, 698, 2/7, 2/8, 70 to 75, 2/9, 96-1527, 1, 2, 272, 185, two, 430, 15, 31, 335, 335, 430, four, two, 2/10, 21, 2/11, 2/12, 430, 303, 451, 430, 2/13, 327, 327, 430, 15, 327, 451, 2, 75, 953, 970, 67, 232, 31, 249, 2/15, 249, 8, 2/17, 16, 96-1527, 1, 2, 2/19, 525, 2/20, 2/1, 96-1527, 1, 3, 2/2, 2/3, 12, 50, 2/4, 2/5, 96-1527, 1, 3, 39, 39, 39-6-303(a, 96-1527, 1, 3, One, 31, 278, 2, 2/6, One, 34, 2/7, 615, 847, 849, 17-18, 2/8, 15-6, 15-38, 15-6-138(b, 2/9, 35, 41, 450, 30, 191, 601, 92, 42, 2/10, 617, 537, 545, 449, 2/11, 1., 2/12, 311, 436, 377, 2/13, 249, 306, 615, 850, 855, 26, 430, 15, 2/15

DATE: 1981, 1981, March 30, 1981, July 2, 1981, 1920, under § 32, 1978, 87, 1979, 1921, 1974, 45, 93, 1974, 1619-1620, 1653-1654, 1683-1684, Mar. 14, 16, 1974, 1974, 1975, 1979, 1976, December 31, 1979, 1978, 1980, 1922, 1923, 1927, 1977, 1980, 1929, 1925, 1977, 1970, 1946, 435 U. S. 734, 1978, 1980, 1978, 1954, 1947, 1937, 1938, 1919, 1981, 1977, 1980, 1978, 1944, 1911, 1972, 1939, 1937, 1974, 1934, 1921, 1937, 1928, 1898, 1949, 1975, 1980, 1979, 1964, 1905, 1903, 1895, 1940, 1940, 1967, 1977, 1975, 1929, 1974, 1934, 1954, 1920, 85, 1976, 1975, 1083, 1975, 1920, 1925, 1975, 35, 1975, 1978, 1976 ed., 1978, 1978, 1981, 1963, 1981, 1977, 1971, 1989, 1976 ed., 3323, 1976 ed., 1976 ed., 95-1749, 1824, 1832, 1834-1837, 1839, 1977, 1978, 1822, 1835, 1979, 1970, 1942, 1978, 1957, 1962, 1931, 1931, 1980, 5, 1938, twelve and a half, 283 U. S. 183, 1931, 1953, 1846, 1977, 1979, 1979, 1980, 1977, 1980, 1980, 1979, 435 U. S. 734, 1978, 1934, H.R. 6625, H.R. 6654, H.R. 7163, H.R. 1313, 1920, 85, 1902, 1093, 17, 18, 1976 ed., 1977, today, January 1, 1979, 1981, 1978, 1980, H.R. 6625, H.R. 6654, H.R. 7163, 1980, 1980, 1978, 1975, 1975, 1979, 1980, 1975, fiscal year 1978, 1980, fiscal year 1979, the year 2010, 22, 1972, the year, 1975, 33 (1978, 1980, 1979, 1979, 1980, 1976, 1946, 1938, 1978, 1976, 1981, today, 1922, today, 1980, 1979, 1946, 1919, today, 1954, 1940, 1978, 1962, 1957, 1978, 1976, 1980, 1979, 1949, 1980, 1977, 1990, 22, pre-1975, 22, 34, 1975, 1974, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1980, 1977, 1980, 1978, 1974, 45, 1974 Mont.Laws, 1620, 1980, 1979, 15-31, 50-54, 1920, 1978, 9620, 3323, 435 U. S. 734, 1978, 1980, 37a, June 5, 1981, 1940, 1964, annual, annual, 1972, 1939, 1937, 1975, 1975, 435 U. S. 734, 1978

LOC: Montana, Montana, West, Montana, Montana, South, West, South, Montana, Montana, the Rocky Mountain States, Western States, Western States, Executive, Midwest, Midwest

PERCENT: 30%, 453 U. S. 614 , 453 U. S. 614 -617, 90%, 453 U. S. 617, 453 U. S. 629 -636, 268 U. S., 453 U. S. 629 , 453 U. S. 633 -636, 30%, at least 50%, 279 U. S. 245 , 445 U. S. 425 , 90%, 80%, 405 U. S. 707 , 417 U. S. 369 , 292 U. S. 40 , 190 U. S. 412 , 311 U. S. 435 , 311 U. S. 435 , 279 U. S. 245 , 417 U. S. Alco Parking Corp., 292 U. S. 40 , 268 U. S., 450 U. S. 311 , 402 U. S. 637, 50 percent, 50%, 50%, 33 States, 445 U. S. 425 , 292 U. S. 40, 37.5%, 52.5%, the remaining 10%, 50%, 40%, the remaining 10%, 9 another 40%, approximately 25%, more than 50%, 70-75%, as much as 90%, 30%, only 0.4%, 11.4%, almost 20%, at least 50%, 29 Vand, 100%, 434 U. S. 429 , 40%, 68%, 10%, 33%, about 20%, approximately 17 1/2%, 5%, An additional 40%, Ninety percent, 20%, 311 U. S. 435 , 405 U. S. 707 , 300 U. S.

PERSON: Supremacy Clauses, Heisler, Brady, J., STEWART, J., MARSHALL, Supremacy Clauses, Resolutions Nos, Fossil Fuel Taxation, Art, Heisler, Brady, Heisler, Helson Randolph v. Kentucky, Hunt, Nippert, Brady, Moorman Mfg, Brady, Joseph v. Carter & Weekes Stevedoring Co., Heisler, Lewis v. BT Investment Managers, Inc., Heisler, McLeod, J. E. Dilworth Co., Hunt, Clark, Paul Gray, Hamilton, Carmichael v. Southern Coal Coke Co., Thomas v. Gay, Ott, J., Gottlieb, Bellas Hess, Holmes, Nippert, Hamilton, Carmichael v. Southern Coal & Coke Co., Nippert, Supp, Pub, Supp, Orrin W. Fox Co., Alessi v. Rabestos-Manhattan, Jones, Perez v. Campbell, Supp, Supp, Supp, Legislative History, Representative Eckhardt, Legislative History, Legislative History, Art, Art, Wickard v. Filburn, Nat, Brown, Heisler, Hellerstein, Clark, Paul Gray, P. Hartman, Hamilton, Supp, POWELL, STEVENS, Brady, Vento, R. Rice, H.R.Rep, Statement 55a, Vento, Art, H.R.Rep, J. Wharton, Krutilla, Freeman, Hewit, Brady, Nat, Hellerstein, Ante, Ante, Heisler, Nippert, Nippert, Nippert, Nippert, McGoldrick, Rice, Brown, Nat, R. Posner, Hellerstein, H.R.Rep, H. P. Hood Sons, Du Mond, Holmes, H.R.Rep, Vento, Ann, Nat, Krutilla, Pub, Supp, J., Ante, J. C. Penney, J., Clark, Paul Gray, Clark, Montana, J.

ORDINAL: third, fourth, first, Second, first, third, fourth, fourth, fourth, fourth, first, fourth, fourth, fourth, first, first, fourth, first, fourth, second, 96th, 97th, 96th, first, first, fourth, fourth, fourth, fourth, fourth, second, fourth, fourth

WORK_OF_ART: the Supremacy Clause, Mont.Code Ann, Supremacy Clause, the Laws of the United States, The Open Economy: Justice Frankfurter and the Position of the Judiciary, Mont.Code Ann, Complete Auto Transit, Brown, The Open Economy: Justice Frankfurter and the Position of the Judiciary, Subcommittee on Fossil Fuel Taxation, Mont.Code Ann.

TIME: 32 of the Act

MONEY: over $5.4 million, 417 , 1920 Act, 3, 790 Section 601(a)(2, approximately 2, approximately 34 cents per ton, $33.6 million, less than $40 million, more than $20 billion, 40 cents, 34 cents, 2.08, 2

PRODUCT: Heisler, 397 U. S. 137 , 397 U. S. 137 , Heisler, Heisler, Table 3

FAC: Illinois Revenue Dept

EVENT: the 1975 Amendments, the 1975 Amendments, U.S.C. § 8401(a)(2, the 1975 Amendments

NORP: §, §, §, Indian, § 9(a, Arab, American, §, d., d.

View Full Judgment


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organize Client Files //