Haryana State Indusl.Devt.Corp.Ltd. Vs. Udal and ors.Etc.Etc.

Decided On : Jul-02-2013

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: the Land Acquisition Act, Section 4, Section 6, Section 4 of the Act, Section 6, Section 4, Section 6, Section 4, Section 6, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Phase-II, Section 18 of the Act, Section 54, P8, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Sector 41, Rs 10, Section 54

ORG: THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL, Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation Limited, No.29009, Haryana High Court, Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation Limited, Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation, HSIIDC, Industrial Model Township, the Government of Haryana, Manesar, Manesar, Khoh, Kasan, Kasan, Manesar, Kasan, Manesar, Phases-II, Manesar, Court, Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation, the Land Acquisition Collector, the Reference Court, Block A, National Highway 8, the Reference Court, Rs.3,91,196.97, the Land Acquisition Collector, The Reference Court, National Highway 8, Block B, Haryana High Court, HSIIDC, the High Court, Court, Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation, Ext, Ext, Corporation, the State Government, Ext, Ext, the High Court, Ext, the State Government, Ext, Manesar, Corporation, Single Judges, Court, The Land Acquisition Collectors, The Land Acquisition Collectors, Corporation, Corporation, HSIIDC, Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation Limited v., Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation Limited, Court, Review Petition, Shri D.C., M/s Heritage Furniture, Ext, DCN International Ltd., Ext, M/s Heritage Furniture, M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., M/s Heritage Furniture, M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., Board of Directors, M/s Duracell, Directors, the Board of Directors of M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., Directors, M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., Duracell Inc. USA, M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., Duracell Inc. USA, M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., M/s Duracell Inc., M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., Lattu Finance &, Investments Ltd., M/s Duracell, P) Ltd., M/s, Gillette India Ltd., M/s Duracell, M/s Heritage Furniture, Indian Shaving Products Ltd., Indian Shaving Products Ltd., Gillette India Ltd., M/s Lattu Finance &, Investments Ltd., M/s Duracell Inc., Civil Appeal No.6561, Ext, Court, Board of Directors, Court, Board of Directors, Board, Gillette India Ltd., Ext, Lattu Finance &, Investments Ltd., Ext, Time Master, Sale Deed No.5431, Ext, the Reference Court, Time Master, Vinot Kumar, Time Master, P) Ltd., Village Naharpur, Tower, Manesar Allotment, Manesar, D-5, D-9, SCO, Manesar, Manesar, Manesar, the Land Acquisition Collector, |Chahi, Kusla |2,25,000 |1,75,000 |1,75,000 |3,60,000, the Land Acquisition Collector, The Reference Court, the High Court, The Reference Court, Court.14, Manesar, the Land Acquisition Collector, The Reference Court, HSIIDC, the Reference Court, Ext, HSIIDC, Phases-II, Manesar, State, Court, HSIIDC, Exhibits P4 to, National Highway No.8, No.13, Manesar, Rs.4,50,00,000/-, State, HSIIDC, State, HSIIDC, State, Court, Court, the Supreme Court, HSIIDC, Exhibit P38, M/s Kohli Holdings Private Limited, HSIIDC, State, National Highway No.8, Housing Project, National Highway No.8.33, Ex P38, the National Highway, National Highway, the National Highway, the State Highway, M/s Kohli Holdings Pvt. Ltd., HSIIDC, Court, Court, Court, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited, Court, HSIIDC, the High Court, National Highway 8, National Highway 8, KMP Express Way, National Highway 8.5, HSIIDC, M/s. Honda Motorcycles and, Scooters India, High Court, HSIIDC, Executive Engineer, Karnataka Housing Board, Land Acquisition Officer, Gadag, Maruti Suzuki India Limited, Phases-II, Manesar, Maruti Udyog Limited, HSIIDC, Manesar, State, Maruti Udyog Limited, the Reference Court, the High Court, Maruti Udyog Limited, Court, Vikas, Maruti Udyog Limited, Maruti Udyog Limited, Maruti Udyog Limited, Government, Court, Royal Orchid Hotels Limited, L.A.C. No.34/2008, Maruti Udyog Limited, Exhibit P38, the Reference Court, Court, Exhibit P38, Court, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited, HSIIDC, M/s. Honda Motorcycles and, Scooters India, the Reference Court, the High Court, the State Government/HSIIDC, the High Court, Maruti Udyog Limited, the High Court, The State Government/HSIIDC, the High Court, Court

DATE: 4940, 17962-18059 of 2011, 18660-18666, 24153-24157 of 2011, 2011, 2011, 4208-4213, 33626-33628 of 2011, 2012, 2012, 2011, 2011, 2011, 2011, 2011, 2011, 2011, 2011, 4149-4159, 2012, 2012, 5019-30, 17422-17433, 2012, 2012, 2012, 2012, 2012, 29021-29022 of 2012, 34068-34095, 1894, 10.11.1995, 1380, 15.11.2002, 7.3.2002, 2010, 15.11.1994, 3.4.1997, 2010, 2012, 2012, 1992, 1993, 16-9-1994, the year 1993, the year 1994, 1994, 30-4-1994, 14-12-1993, 14-12-1993, 16-9-1994, 16-9-1994, 31-5-1994, 31-5-1994, 31-5-1994, 16-9-1994, 1994, the year 2000, December 2000, the year 1994, 4,84,375, the year 1994, 20-9-1996, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996, 2,75,000 10”20, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996 1, 9-1996, 7-1996 1, December 2006, 2006, Sector 1, 18-8-2009, 1,82,00,000 11, 1,62,50,000 13, 1,40,00,000 17, 1,37,00,000 18, 2376, 1,25,928.58, Sector 1, 11-8-2010, 1,88,50,000 5, Sector 1, 11-8-2010, 7 years 3 months, 21 days, 24.12.2003, 1994, the years 1994 and 2002, the year 1994, 2006, more than 4 years, the year 1994, 14, 15, two years, the year 1994, the year 1994, 7-8 years, the year 1994, 7 years, 3 months, 2010, annual, 33, 2010, the year 1994, two years, 2010, 2008, 2011, 2010, 2011, annual, 2011, 2006, about four years, 2008, 1980, 1995, 2011, 2008, 2011, about 7 years, 3 months, 1994, 2002, annual, annual, annual, annual, more per year, years, the nineties, previous years, only a few years, only a few years, 1992, annual, 1970, 1980, years, annual, the immediate preceding year, some years, the year to year, the previous year's, Year, 12.1”12., 12.10 + 1.21, + 1, 14.6”14., 16.10 19, 1987, annual, the five years 1988, 1989, 1990,, 1991, 1992, the year 1989, the years 1990,, 1991, 1992, the year 1990, 1.30, the years 1991 and 1992, the base year, 13.31, 32, 2011, annual, annual, four months, today, 02 2013

CARDINAL: NOs.4967-73, 82, 4993-95, 17, 33, 39, 43, 30.04.1994, 30.09.1995, 17, 15.11.1994, 17, 16, 6.3.2002, 12, 3, 26.2.2002, 18, 11, 28.3.1997, two, two, 5.9.2008, 15.11.1994, 17.08.2010, 26, two, 7, 1/4th, one, 1/4th, 1, 20, 11, 2.7.2012, 7, 13.1.2011, 7, 4 to 9, five, 6, 49, 2, one, five, 6, 6-12, 16-3-1994, almost 11, 16-3-1994, 6, 20, 31, one, 62, 7, 31, 2,42,00,000, two, forty-two, three, two, 9-6-1994, 9, three, three, one, two, 28-4-2004, one, one, thirteen, 28-4-2004, 17, one, 25,00,000, twenty-five, 1, 11, 20, 17, 15, 18, 5, 2009“5, 28, 13,62,00,000, 96, 13, one, sixty-two, 1, 25, 1”20, 9”20, 15, 3, 25, 25, 16, 14, 25, 2”5, 12, 12, 30-6-2006, 680.Rs 95.10, 1,45,518, 1,14,284.50, 1, 144, 144, 144, T-7 144 Rs, 144, 108, 12, 108, 108, 14, 108, 15, 108, 108, 108, 19, 108, 1, 3, 4, 1”144, 12, 14.Rs, 972, 12, 22.7.2003, 13, 15, 6.3.2002, 19, 25, 26, four, 26, 2.2.2000, 20, 21, 29, 30, two, 2.2.2000, 22, 69, 15, five, 34, 69, 15, five, 69, 15, 23, 14, two, 23.11.1999, two, three, 12, 2, more than 20000, 3, 2, 2, 7.8.2008, 10, 30, two, 12/15%.31, 19, three, four, only around half, up to four, two, 1, 11.00, 10.00, 1.00, 11.0”11, 1, 12.00 11.00 + 1.10, 1, 13.00, 13.3”13, 14.00, 13.31 + 1.33, 1, 15.00, 14.64 + 1.46, 1, 12, 1.20, 10 or Rs, 12.10, 8, 91.Of, 23.11.1999, Rs.37,40,000, 34

GPE: No.33593, Dhana, Haryana, Village, District Gurgaon, Village Naurangpur, District Gurgaon, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, K 583.Rs101.50, Pran Sukh’s, Kusla, Pran Sukh’s, Pran Sukh’s, Pran Sukh’s, No.4646, Pran Sukh’s, Sanath, Pran Sukh’s, landowners.33

PERSON: JUDGMENT G. S. Singhvi, District Gurgaon, Naharpur Kasan, Bas Kusla, Naharpur Kasan, Bas Kusla, Bas Haria, Pran Sukh, Pran Sukh, Paragraphs 22, Ram, Pran Sukh, Kherka Daula, Rs 15,73,289, Kumar Poddar, Ms Jyotsana Poddar, Shri Gurbunder, Singh Gill, Kumar Poddar, Ms Jyotsana Poddar, Singh Gill, India, D-7, D-12 108 Rs, Mumkin, |2.2.2000 |30,000, crores|1,74,039.78, |93.00, below:“29, per square yard, Paragraphs 31, Shri Parag P. Tripathi, Jivanbhai Patel, Shri Tripathi, V.K. Bali, Kumar v. Special Tahsildar, Dave, Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Patwalia, Patwalia, Himalayan Tiles, Francis Victor Coutinlo, Giyan Devi, DDA v. Bhola Nath Sharma, G. Jayarama, Jivanbhai Patel, Paragraphs 12 to, Singh, Ramanjulu, Bipin Kumar, Rs 10, Valliyammal, Exhibit PW9/, J.[G.S. SINGHVI, J.JULY, JYOTI MUKHOPADHAYA

NORP: J.1, Punjab, Punjab, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, P-1, Vasika, Vasika, Haria, Rs.1,254.72, Rs.8000

LOC: Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Act.30, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single

QUANTITY: over 700 acres, 256 acres, 490 acres, 595 acres 5, 567 acres 4, 965 acres, 500 yards, 500 yards, 12 acres, 1,35,000 per acre, about 2 km, about 12 acres, more than 2.25 acres, 5K 13.Rs1,13,00,000 1,60,00,000, 1,60,213.67 per square yard, 30,000 square meters, 30,000 square meters, two acres, 30,000 square meters, two acres, 4-5 kilometers, about one kilometer, two acres, 30,000 square meters, 60 meter, 26.778 acres, 771 acres, 600 acres, 501.8 acres, 7875 square meters, 13 per square metre

EVENT: Phase-II

PRODUCT: Rs.4,13,600, Shri Saroj, Shri Saroj, Para 5, Sale, acre.14”17, 1,33,50,000 Total, D-10 108 Rs, D-14 108 Rs, D-15, D-16 108 Rs 1,92,00,000, |7,50,000, |10,00,000, |7,50,000, |3,60,000, Rs.37,40,000, Rs.37,40,000

ORDINAL: first, first, second, first, first, first, first, third

FAC: Village Naharpur Kasan, Village Naharpur Kasan, 4”14, Tower Area, Rs.|Gair Mumkin, National Highway No.8, National Highway No.8, National Highway 8, Delhi Highway

PERCENT: 20%, 20%, 12%, 80%, 50%, 12%, 12%, 50%, 15%, 15%, 30%, 12%, more than 7.5%, 15%, only 12%, an additional 30%, 40%, 15%, 12%, 15%, 30%, 30% to 50%, 1% or, 2%, about 10% to 15%, about 5% to 7.5%, 10%, 10%, 10%, 50%, 12/15%

TIME: 95,21,160 i.e., 35,78,50,000 i.e. Rs 1,50,610.26

MONEY: 10.00