Sierra Club Vs. Morton

Decided On : Apr-19-1972

Court : US Supreme Court

LAW: the Administrative Procedure Act, the Administrative Procedure Act, the Administrative Procedure Act, the Administrative Procedure Act, Rule 15, the Communications Act, Reade v. Ewing, the Constitution of the United States, Article III of the Constitution, Constitution

ORG: Sierra Club, Morton - 405, U.S. Supreme Court, Sierra Club, Sierra Club, THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS , THE NINTH CIRCUIT, Syllabus, the Sequoia National Forest, The District Court, The Court of Appeals, Court, BURGER, C.J., WHITE, BRENNAN, REHNQUIST, Court, Sequoia National Park, the Sequoia National Forest, Congress, The United States Forest Service, the Forest Service, Walt Disney Enterprises, Inc., Disney, Disney, the Forest Service, the Forest Service, the Department of the Interior, the Sierra Club, the Forest Service, the Department of the Interior, Club, Disney, Club, Mineral King, Sierra Club, the District Court, the Sierra Club's, the Court of Appeals, the Ninth Circuit, the Sierra Club, Congressional and Constitutional authority, the Court of Appeals, the Sierra Club, The Sierra Club, the Sierra Club, Congress, Sierra Club, APA, Page 405 U. S. 733 , Camp, , APA, the Comptroller of the Currency, the Sierra Club, APA, Aesthetic, Mineral King, Mineral King, Sequoia National Park, The Sierra Club, Disney, Club, Club, Club, the Sierra Club, Scripps-Howard Radio v., FCC, FCC, Court, Scripps Page 405 U. S. 737, Commission, Court, Congress, Commission, FCC, Sanders Bros. Radio Station, Congress, Commission, Congress, Scripps-Howard, Scripps-Howard, Congress, See Data Processing, APA, Hardin, APA, The Sierra Club, Nation, the Sierra Club, APA, the Sierra Club, the Court of Appeals, Sierra Club, the District Court, the Forest Service, the Forest Service, the Department of the Interior, Congress, Congress, FCC, Sanders Bros. Radio Station, Flast, Harlan, Associated Industries, Standing to Sue in Public Actions, Yale, Kansas City Power & Light Co., D.C. 273, Duba v. Schuetzle, Alabama Power Co., Tennessee Electric Power Co., TVA, Hardin, Kentucky Utilities Co., T. & S.F. R. Co., FCC, Sanders Bros. Radio Station, the Sierra Club's, Plaintiff Sierra Club, the Sierra Club, the Sierra Club, Court, the Wilderness Society, the Sierra Club, Club, the Court of Appeals, the Sierra Club, the Sierra Club, the District Court, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the Court of Appeals, the Second Circuit, Citizens Committee, Scripps-Howard Court's, FCC, Sanders Bros. Radio Station, Environmental Defense Fund, Hardin, DDT, Office of Communication of the United Church of Christ v., FCC, D.C. 328, FCC, FPC, FPC, Federal Security Administration, Volpe, Environmental Defense Fund, Corps of Engineers, Izaak Walton League v., St. Clair, FPC, the Federal Power Commission, Sierra Club, Inanimate, elk, Hano, The Sierra Club, the Sierra Club, The District Court, the Sierra Club, Mineral King, Page 405 U. S. 745 , Congress, the National Environmental Policy Act, the Council on Environmental Quality, Fed, Congress, Congress, Page 405 U. S. 746 , the Interstate Commerce Commission, Office of Communication of the United Church of Christ v., FCC, D.C. 328, FPC, Coordinating Committee, AEC, Environmental Defense Fund, Ruckelhaus, Environmental Defense Fund, HEW, FPC, The Federal Regulatory Agencies In Perspective: Administrative Limitations, B.C.Ind. & Com, The Forest Service, Congress, Guadalupes, the Quetico Superior, A Sand County Almanac, Camp, , Data Processing Service, G. Gilmore & C. Black, Camanche, Coke, Hospital, Dartmouth College, the Forest Service, Walt Disney Productions, the Forest Service, Disney, Disney, Disney, Disney, Disney, The Forest Service, Cabinet, the Government Printing Office, The Vested Oracles: How Industry Regulates Government, the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Relations, the Senate Committee on Government Operations, the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Relations of the Senate Committee on Government Operations, Cong, the Federal Trade Commission, L.J., the Regulatory Ideal, L.J. 869, R. Berkman & K. Viscusi, The Ralph Nader Study Group Report, The Bureau of Reclamation 155, The Interstate Commerce Omission, The Ralph Nader Study Group Report, the Interstate Commerce Commission, Transportation, The Chemical Feast, The Ralph Nader Study Group Report, the Food and Drug Administration, Interior, the Forest Service, the Department of Agriculture, the Multiple-Use Sustained-Yield Act, The Forest Service, Forest Service, Service, N.Y. Times, Wagner, Resources Report/Lumbermen, the Forest Service, Forest Service, The Forest Service's, N.Y. Times, the Forest Service, the Subcommittee on Public Land of the Senate Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, the Monongahela National Forest, Forest Service, Monongahela National Forest, the Bitterroot National Forest, the University of Montana, the Forest Service's, Prospect, American Forests, Nov.1971, the Interior Walter Hickel, The U.S. Forest Service, Forest Service, Agriculture, Forest Management, the Congress 44, Fish Resources of the West Coast, Congress, Congress, the Forest Service's, Timber Resources, Pupfish National Monument, U.S. 727app| , APPENDIX, J., DISSENTING Extract From Oral Argument of, Founders, Congress, the Executive Branch, Court, Court, Congress, Congress, Oral Arg, the Sierra Club, Court, Court, Data Processing Service, Camp, , Court, Nation, Court, the Forest Service's, Court, The District Court, the Sierra Club, the Court of Appeals, Court, the District Court, The Sierra Club, Court, the Court of Appeals, the District Court, the Sierra Club, the Sierra Club, Court, Sierra Club, Court, Congress, Disney, the Sierra Club, Disney, Court, The State of California, State, Disney, Court, Court, Hardin, Citizens Committee, FPC, Izaak Walton League v., St. Clair, Environmental Defense Fund, Corps of Engineers, Environmental Defense Fund, Corps of Engineers, Sierra Club, Hardin, Izaak Walton League, See National Automatic Laundry & Cleaning Council v. Shultz, D.C. 274, Island Creek Coal Co., Environmental Defense Fund, HEW, Hardin, Promontorie, Mannor

GPE: U.S., U.S., U.S., Tulare County, California, the State of California, the United States, California, U.S., Cincinnati, Ohio, U.S., MR, MR, United States, United States, Chicago, Atchison, Memphis, Tennessee, the State of California, San Francisco, California, the United States, wanton, S.Cal, N.Y., Mag., Browning, America, D.C., D.C., Sunfish Pond, New Jersey, Maine, West Texas, Minnesota, MR, Recent Cases, Minn., Note, Mich., Cyclopedia, Sutton, Those Hills, California, Washington, Cong., Hearings, Massel, Wyoming, West Virginia, Montana, Calif., Smokey, Washington, U.S., Wyoming, Rwanda, Germany, Wisconsin, Iowa, Pandora, MR, U.S., Alaska, D.C., Mankinde

DATE: 1972, 1972, November 17, 1971, April 19, 1972, 24, JJ, 1926, each year, the late 1940's, 1965, summer, three-year, January, 1969, 30-year, 1965, June, 1969, two days, 24, 33, the same day, recent years, D.C. 391, 1093, 1097, July 3, 1926, 44, 43, 1969, 1033, 1968, 1964, 1892, many years, 1934, 1093, 1958, D.C. 391, 1093, 1097, 1205, 1212, 7373, 1312, 1317, 1830, daily, 1972, Aug. 17, 1969, March 1972, 1969, 4321, 7724, 1938, Years later, 1003-1004, D.C. 33, 1109, D.C. 74, 1083, 1970, 1949, 1970, 1970, 1968, 1957, 1869, 1954, 1927, 1928, 1928, 1963, 1881, 1819, Today, annually, 1949, 1965, 1978, annual, a busy day, 1970, 1968, 22, 1965, each year, 1971, annually, Monthly, July 1971, 1970, S. 1637, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1970, 1970, 1961, 1960, 1897, 35, 1905, Feb. 1, 1905, 1960, annual, 1950, 1971, Nov. 15, 1971, 1971, annually, Nov. 14, 1971, 1971, 36971, 1970, 1962, 1971, Monthly, 1971, 1970, 1962, 24, this century, 80 A. D., billions of years, Nov. 1971, 1953, two centuries, today, Two centuries, a century, 2141, Dec. 1971, nearly 200 years, the past 20 or 25 years, the years, 1970, 1970, 1968, today, this late date, 1956, 20 years ago, today, a day, daily, the good old days, today, D.C. 391, 1093, 1096-1097, 1970, 1970, 1965, 1312, 1316-1317, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1083, 1085, 1970

PERSON: Morton, Mineral King, STEWART, J., DOUGLAS, J., J., BLACKMUN, J., POWELL, STEWART, Mineral King, Mineral King, Baker, Carr, Barlow, Collins, Barlow, Mineral King, Howard, Sanders, POWELL, REHNQUIST, Muskrat, Johnson, Luther v. Borden, Art, Cohen, Cohen, Berger, Jaffe, McKay, Citizens, Preserve Overton Park, Volpe, Volpe, Administrative Law Treatise §§, Scenic Hudson, Crowther v. Seaborg, Scenic Hudson, Alexis de Tocqueville's, De Tocqueville's, DOUGLAS, Mineral King, Morton, Mineral King, Mickey Mouse, Harper, Mineral King, Tuolumne Meadows, Appendix, Pub, Russell E. Train, Reg, Olney, M. Josephson, Moss v. CAB, Udall, Calvert Cliffs', Scenic Hudson, Mineral King, Aldo Leopold, Barlow, Collins, Flast, Cohen, BRENNAN, Barlow, Collins, Tucker, Reid, Barry, W. Fletcher, Marshall, Mineral King Valley, Mineral King Valley, Thar, Michael Frome, M. Frome, Lee Metcalf, Metcalf, S.1964, Johnson, R. Fellmeth, J. Turner, Prob, J. Landis, Douglas, Gale McGee, nursemaid, Jennings Randolph, Jennings Randolph, Lee Metcalf, Behan, Reich, W. Hickel, Chapman, M. Frome, H. Pyles ed.1970, Nature, Aldo Leopold, Cranston, Michael Frome, Cranston, BRENNAN, BLACKMUN, JUSTICE BLACKMUN, Barlow, Collins, Flast, Cohen, Mineral King, Barlow, DOUGLAS, Mineral King, De Tocqueville, John Donne, Volpe, Scenic Hudson, Upper Pecos Assn, Honchok

CARDINAL: 405, 70-34, 405, 10, 433, 1, six, 14,000, 2, 5, 701, 433, two, 30, 401, 369, 186, 3, 10, 5, 702, 150, 5, 6, 9, 10, 12, 13, 397, 138, 395, 428, 14, 15, 16, 1, 6, 821, 16, 688, 2, four, 16, 497, 16, 1, 16, 16, 45c, 3, 1, one, 134, 694, 704, 78, 837, 116, 4, 96, 281, 225, 924, 932, 278, 912, 914, 303, 570, 574, 5, 6, 8, 3, approximately 78,000, approximately 27,000, One, 15, 9, 425, 97, 105, 10, 48, 12, 22.05-22.07, 13, 138, 395, 428, 123, 339, 359, 994, 354, 608, 615, 205, 630, 631, 312, 14, 9, 325, 728, 313, 616, at least one, 15, 12, 16, 280, 102, 2/1, 45, 450, 2/2, 2/3, 2/4, 2/5, 25, 65, 91, 83, 852, 42, 36, one, 2/6, 139, 150, 152, 430, 891, 893, 123, 337, 359, 994, 146, 449, 142, 439, 584, 138, 381, 428, 354, 608, 620, 11, 565, one, 2/7, 2/8, 2/9, 204, 2/1, 2/2, 8, 448, 209, 2/3, 93, 112, 846, 12, 295, 26, 545, 1, 2/4, 77, 973, 518, 2/5, about 70,000, 10, at least 100, 3,300, nine, two, 10, 20, 25, 103, 107, 206, 260, 5, 1, 2/6, about 1,500, 3, 45, 2d, 92d, 59, 788, 59, 874, 906, 26, 181, 189, 13, 2/7, 30, 16, 551, 33, 628, 16, 472, 154, 74, 215, 16, millions, 48, 1, 3, hundreds, 60, 2., 1, 7, 9, 116, 91, 14, 4, 50, 381-400, 130, 3, 16, at least one, 60, 23, 2/8, 5 million, 20 million, one million, 200,000, 4, 2/9, 92d, 74, three, 31-35, 2, one, 10, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, one, two, 1, 16, 497, 66,000, 2, two, 1, 14,000, 10, 20, only two, 700, 14,000, four, 14,000, 3,500, 24, 3,500, two, about 300, five, one, two, 2, 14,000, 3/2, 138, 394, 428, 425, 97, 101, 400, 949, 354, 608, 313, 324, 878, 325, 728, 734, 325, 99, 107-112, 328, 332, 333, 329, 504, 510, 143, 278, 443, 689, 693, 441, 232, 234, 138, 381, 383, 2, 428, 326, 988, 991, 3/2

LOC: the Mineral King Valley, the Northern District, the San Francisco Bay Area, Hudson Valley, Hudson Valley, Sierra Nevada, Fla. 849, Valley, Valley, Yosemite Valley, Valley, the High Sierras, the Virunga Mountains, Round River, the Middle Ages, Valley, Hammond, Hudson Valley, Sea, Europe

MONEY: $35 million, 937, at least $3 million, $35.3 million, about $75 million, 5.6 billion board feet, 13.74 billion, about 2 billion years

QUANTITY: 80 acres, 20 miles, 3 K. Davis, live 3,000 miles, 160-acre, 35,000-acre, one inch, 35.3-million-dollar, 80-acre, five-acre, 80-acre, 3,100 overnight, 9.2 miles, 1,200 per hour, 615-617, 879-880

FAC: Sequoia National Park, Sequoia National Park, Sequoia National Park, Overton Park, Overton Park, Camp, Dec.1971, the Sequoia Game Refuge, Sequoia National Park, Mineral King

WORK_OF_ART: Mineral King, Mineral King, The Battle of Mineral King, The Politicos 526, The Regulatory Process, Hearings on Management Practices on the Public Lands, S.Doc, Mineral King

ORDINAL: first, First, Second, Third, third, first, 91st, third, first, first, second, first

PRODUCT: Flast v. Cohen,, 397 U. S. 159 , L.J. 816, Floete, 397 U. S. 159 , 386, 4 Wheat, Watchmen, Geo, Geo, Spessart, Spessart, Spessart, 397 U. S. 159

PERCENT: 316 U. S. 4 , 401 U. S. 402 , 240%

NORP: NAACP, Ickes, amici, §, F.Supp, F.Supp, F.Supp, Protectionists, American, Indian, European, Romans, American, Scotch, F.Supp, F.Supp, F.Supp, F.Supp, Stans, F.Supp, F.Supp, F.Supp, Iland

EVENT: K.B. 1612

TIME: 12 hours, one every 12 seconds