IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT: THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN THURSDAY,THE27H DAYOF NOVEMBER20146TH AGRAHAYANA, 1936 OP (CAT).No. 173 of 2014 (Z) -------------------------------------- AGAINST THE ORDER
IN OA8212014 of CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,ERNAKULAM BENCH DATED710.2014 PETITIONERS:
1. M.K.SHAJI AGED56YEARS, FOREMAN (A1), AVIONICS I, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 2. M.T.SUNIL KUMAR, MECHANICS HSI(AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 3. SOLE P.MATHEW, MECHANIC HSI(AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 4. JAGADEESAN P.K.,FOREMAN (AI) QAC, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 5. K.V.MOHANAN, CHARGEMAN (AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 6. P.VELAYUDHAN, CHAGEMAN (AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 7. M.K.HAREENDRAN, FOREMAN (AI), SEAKING AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVALBASE, KOCHI-4.
8. S.SANALKUMAR, MECHANIC HS I(AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 9. R.JAYARAJ, CHARGEMAN (AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 10. AJI K. MCM(AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 11. JOSE PETER, FOREMAN (AE), CRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD,NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4 OP (CAT).No. 173 of 2014 (Z) ::
2. ::
12. V.M.UMESH, MECHANIC HS I (AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 13. R.RAKHEE, MECHANIC HSI(AI), AVIONICS I, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 14. P.PRAVEEN, MECHANIC HS I (AI) LRS NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4.
15. VIJITH T.K., MECHANIC HS I (AL), LRS NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
16. A.P.RAJAPPAN, MECHANIC HS I (AR) AVIONICS III NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD,NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 17. MOHAMMED SAIJU, MECHANIC HS I (AS) SRF, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI418. SASIKUMAR N., CHARGEMAN (AI) NAQAS NAVALBASE, KOCHI419. RAMKUMAR CHARGEMAN (AE), HRD, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVALBASE, KOCHI-4.
20. SATHISH G.MENON, MECHANIC HS II (AE), CRS NAVALBASE, KOCHI-4.
21. HARI K.G., CHARGEMAN (AE), CHETAK HANGAR, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -14.
22. V.I.BABY, CHARGEMAN (AI), LRS NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 23. T.A.PAUL, CHARGEMAN (AI), LRS NAVALAIRCRAFT YARDNAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 24. K.C.SANTHEESH, MECHANIC SK (AI), LRS NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 25. P.T.SATHEESH, MECHANIC HS II (AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 26. ANITHA JOSHI, MECHANIC SK (AE), AEROS NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4. OP (CAT).No. 173 of 2014 (Z) ::
3. ::
27. LEELA M.K., MECHANIC SK (AE), AEROS NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4.
28. P.J.AJI JOSE, MECHAINCI HS I (AE), AEROS NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4.
29. P.BALACHANDRAN, CHARGEMAN (AI), NAQAS, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4 30. M.K.BINDHU, CHAGEMAN (AR), NAQAS NAVAL BASE, KOCHI-4 31. N.LIJO JOSEPH, MECHANIC HS I (AR), AVIONICS III, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 32. SIVANAND GOUDA, MECHANIC SK (A1), AVIONICS I, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 33. MANOOP K.M., MECHANIC SK(A1) LRS NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
34. GEORGE KURUVILLA, MECHANIC HS I (AE) CRS, NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
35. A ANEESH, MECHANIC HS I (AE) CRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
36. B.B.UNNIKRISHNAN, MECHANIC HS II (AE) CRS, NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
37. ANOOB RAJ, MECHANIC SK (AE), CRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
38. K.ANTONY RODRIGUES, CHARGEMAN (AE), CRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
39. M.V.JOSE, MECHANIC SK (AE), CRS, NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
40. R.N.MENON, FOREMAN (AE), NAQAS, NAVALBASE, KOCHI - 4 41. V.V.MATHAI, CHARGEMAN (AS), QAC, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
42. K.RAJAGOPAL, MECHANIC HS I (AR) CHETAK HANGAR NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD,NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4 43. SANDEEP YADAV JADHAV MECHANIC SK (AE) CRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD,NAVALBASE, KOCHI -4. OP (CAT).No. 173 of 2014 (Z) ::
4. ::
44. A.V.PUSHPALATHA, MECHANIC SK (AE), CRS, NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
45. K.K.LEELAMANI, MECHANIC SK (AE), CRS, NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
46. MURALEEDHARAN A.K., CHARGEMA (AI), SHERAF,NAVALAIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
47. P.J.MATHEW, FOREMAN (AI), LRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4.
48. JOEBOY STEPHEN, CHARGEMAN (AE), CRS, NAVAL AIRCRAFT YARD NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4. BY ADVS.SRI.S.P.CHALY SRI.DINNY THOMAS SRI.JAISHANKAR V.NAIR SMT.ROSHNI MANUEL RESPONDENTS:
1. UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (NAVY), NEW DELHI110011.
2. SENIOR PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR OF CIVILIAN PERSONNEL SERVICES, INTEGRATED HEAD QUARTERS, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (NAVY) NEW DELHI - 110 011.
3. CHIEF OF NAVAL STAFF, INTEGRATED HEAD QUARTERS, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (NAVY), NEW DELHI110011.
4. FLAG OFFICER COMMANDING -IN-CHIEF, REPRESENTED BY CSO (P&A), HEAD QUARTERS SOUTHERN NAVALCOMMAND, NAVAL BASE, KOCHI -4, KERALA.
5. THE CHAIRMAN, VII CENTRAL PAYCOMMISSION, MINISTRY OF FINANCE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, NEW DELHI110001 R1-R5 BY ADV.SRI.N.NAGARESH, ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL THIS OP (CAT) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON2711-2014, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: OP (CAT).No. 173 of 2014 (Z) APPENDIX PETITIONERS' EXHIBITS: P1: TRUE COPY OF THE OA NO.821/2014 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONERS BEFORE THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM. P2: TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT
DATED7/10/2014 IN O.A NO.821/2014. RESPONDENTS' EXHIBITS: NIL. // TRUE COPY // P.A. TO JUDGE ANTONY DOMINIC & ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JJ.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - O.P.(CAT)No.173 OF2014- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Dated this the 27th day of November, 2014 JUDGMENT
Antony Dominic, J.
The petitioners approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench by filing O.A.821/14. In the O.A. among other prayers, they sought a direction to the fifth respondent/Pay Commission to consider Annexure A19 representation filed by their association. The Tribunal disposed of the O.A. by Ext.P2 order, dated 7th October 2014, directing the petitioners to make available a copy of the representation to the Government of India and requiring the Government of India to consider forwarding the representation to the Pay Commission. It is this order which is under challenge before us.
2. We heard the counsel for the petitioners and the learned Assistant Solicitor General appearing for the respondents. In so far as the prayer made by the petitioners requiring the Pay Commission to consider their representation is concerned, pleading itself shows that the case of the petitioners is that they have already made Annexure A19 representation to the Pay Commission. O.P.(CAT)No.173 OF2014:
2. : Therefore, if such a representation has been received it is entirely for the Pay Commission to deal with the same. Reading of the order passed by the Tribunal shows that the request made by the petitioners before the Tribunal was to direct the respondent to forward Annexure A19 to the Pay Commission. It was taking note of this submission and also the fact that Annexure A19 is addressed to the Pay Commission that the Tribunal directed the petitioners to submit a copy of the representation to the Government of India and the Government of India to consider for forwarding the representation to the Pay Commission. This order passed by the Tribunal, in our view, does not suffer from any illegality for interference. Sd/- ANTONY DOMINIC, Judge Sd/- ANIL K. NARENDRAN, Judge jes