Karma Alias Karamdeo Karmali and ors Vs. State of Jharkhand - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/1008073
CourtJharkhand High Court
Decided OnJul-29-2013
AppellantKarma Alias Karamdeo Karmali and ors
RespondentState of Jharkhand
Excerpt:
inthehighcourtofjharkhandatranchi cr.appeal(db)no.250of2013 1.karma@karamdeokarmali 2.palodevi 3.amritkarmali .......appellants versus thestateofjharkhand .....respondent. coram: honblemr.justiced.n.patel honblemr.justiceshreechandrashekhar. fortheappellants:mr.vishalkr.rai,advocate forthestate:mr.shekharsinha,a.p.p. 04/dated:29 th july,2013 oralorder: perd.n.patel,j.:1. thisappealhasbeenadmittedvideorderdated24 thjune,2013and therecordandproceedingsofsessionstrialno.506of1993wascalled fromthetrialcourtsoastoappreciatetheargumentsforsuspensionof sentence.thiscourthasreceivedtherecordandproceedingsofthetrial courtandwehaveperusedthesame.2. havingheardcounselforboththesidesandlookingtotheevidences onrecord,itappearsthatthereisaprimafaciecaseinfavourofthese appellants.asthecriminalappealispending,wearenotmuchanalyzing theevidencesonrecord,but,sufficeittosaythatlookingtothedeposition givenbytheprosecutionwitnessesfromp.w.2top.w.10,thereisaprima faciecaseinfavouroftheseappellants.3. wetherefore,suspendthesentenceawardedbythetrialcourttothe presentappellants.duringpendencyofthisappeal,theappellantsnamely, (i)karma@karamdeokarmali(ii)palodeviand(iii)amritkarmali,are directedtobereleasedonbailuponexecutingbondofrs.10,000/(rs.ten thousand) each, with two sureties of the like amount each, to the satisfactionoftheadditionalsessionsjudgevi,hazaribagh,inconnection withsessionstrialno.506of1993,ontheconditionthattheseappellants shallbeavailableasandwhentheirpresencearerequiredbythecourt. (d.n.patel,j) (shreechandrashekhar,j.) vk/
Judgment:

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFJHARKHANDATRANCHI Cr.Appeal(DB)No.250of2013 1.Karma@KaramdeoKarmali 2.PaloDevi 3.AmritKarmali .......Appellants Versus TheStateofJharkhand .....Respondent. CORAM: HONBLEMR.JUSTICED.N.PATEL HONBLEMR.JUSTICESHREECHANDRASHEKHAR. FortheAppellants:Mr.VishalKr.Rai,Advocate FortheState:Mr.ShekharSinha,A.P.P. 04/Dated:29 th July,2013 Oralorder: PerD.N.Patel,J.:

1. ThisappealhasbeenAdmittedvideorderdated24 thJune,2013and therecordandproceedingsofSessionsTrialNo.506of1993wascalled fromthetrialcourtsoastoappreciatetheargumentsforsuspensionof sentence.ThisCourthasreceivedtherecordandproceedingsofthetrial courtandwehaveperusedthesame.

2. Havingheardcounselforboththesidesandlookingtotheevidences onrecord,itappearsthatthereisaprimafaciecaseinfavourofthese appellants.Asthecriminalappealispending,wearenotmuchanalyzing theevidencesonrecord,but,sufficeittosaythatlookingtothedeposition givenbytheprosecutionwitnessesfromP.W.2toP.W.10,thereisaprima faciecaseinfavouroftheseappellants.

3. Wetherefore,suspendthesentenceawardedbythetrialcourttothe presentappellants.Duringpendencyofthisappeal,theappellantsnamely, (i)Karma@KaramdeoKarmali(ii)PaloDeviand(iii)AmritKarmali,are directedtobereleasedonbailuponexecutingbondofRs.10,000/(Rs.ten thousand) each, with two sureties of the like amount each, to the satisfactionoftheAdditionalSessionsJudgeVI,Hazaribagh,inconnection withSessionsTrialNo.506of1993,ontheconditionthattheseappellants shallbeavailableasandwhentheirpresencearerequiredbythecourt. (D.N.Patel,J) (ShreeChandrashekhar,J.) VK/