C.C.E., Indore Vs. Shri Namdeo Panjwani (Md of M/S Panjwani Packaging Ltd.) - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/942300
CourtCustoms Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal CESTAT Delhi
Decided OnMar-22-2010
Case NumberCentral Excise Appeal No.2891 of 2007-SM
JudgeThe Honourable Mr. M. Veeraiyan, Member (Technical)
AppellantC.C.E., Indore
RespondentShri Namdeo Panjwani (Md of M/S Panjwani Packaging Ltd.)
Advocates:Shri V.K. Saxena , Authorized Departmental Representative (Jt.CDR) for the Revenue.
Excerpt:
per m. veeraiyan: learned jt. cdr points out that this appeal is in effect a duplication of appeal no.e/2890/2007. when the appeal has been filed by the department in two copies two separate numbers e/2890 and 2891/07 have inadvertently been allotted by the registry. there is only one appeal and therefore, e/2891/07 may be treated as infractuous and closed. 2. in view of the above, appeal no.2891/07 is closed and is accordingly disposed of as the matter already being dealt with in appeal no.e/2890/07.
Judgment:

Per M. Veeraiyan:

Learned Jt. CDR points out that this appeal is in effect a duplication of Appeal No.E/2890/2007. When the appeal has been filed by the Department in two copies two separate numbers E/2890 and 2891/07 have inadvertently been allotted by the registry. There is only one appeal and therefore, E/2891/07 may be treated as infractuous and closed.

2. In view of the above, Appeal No.2891/07 is closed and is accordingly disposed of as the matter already being dealt with in Appeal No.E/2890/07.