The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr. - Court Judgment

Notice (8): Undefined variable: kword [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 120]
Code Context
                                echo "<div class='table-bordered'><b>Excerpt:</b><br/>";

                                    if (trim($desc['Judgement']['casenote'])) {

                                        echo $this->Wand->highlight($this->Excerpt->extractRelevant($kword,strtolower(strip_tags($desc['Judgement']['casenote']))), $query);
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 120
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 120]
Code Context
                                echo "<div class='table-bordered'><b>Excerpt:</b><br/>";

                                    if (trim($desc['Judgement']['casenote'])) {

                                        echo $this->Wand->highlight($this->Excerpt->extractRelevant($kword,strtolower(strip_tags($desc['Judgement']['casenote']))), $query);
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 120
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Notice (8): Undefined variable: kword [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 123]
Code Context
                                    }

                                //highest occurence of word in the judgement

                                echo $this->Wand->highlight($this->Excerpt->extractRelevant($kword,strtolower(strip_tags($desc['Judgement']['judgement']))), $query) . "</div>";
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 123
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 123]
Code Context
                                    }

                                //highest occurence of word in the judgement

                                echo $this->Wand->highlight($this->Excerpt->extractRelevant($kword,strtolower(strip_tags($desc['Judgement']['judgement']))), $query) . "</div>";
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 123
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 0
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Maclean, J.

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 1
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 2
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 3
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 4
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Mitter, J.

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 5
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 6
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

[1]

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 7
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 8
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 9
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 10
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 11
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 12
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 13
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 14
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 15
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109

records its findingh.

Notice (8): Undefined variable: query [APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144]
Code Context
                                         echo $this->Adsense->display('responsive_rect'); 

                                        }

                                        echo html_entity_decode($this->Wand->highlight($content[$i], $query));
$viewFile = '/home/legalcrystal/app/View/Case/amp.ctp'
$dataForView = array(
	'title_for_layout' => 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | ',
	'desc' => array(
		'Judgement' => array(
			'id' => '874579',
			'acts' => '',
			'appealno' => '',
			'appellant' => 'The Empress',
			'authreffered' => '',
			'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
			'caseanalysis' => null,
			'casesref' => '',
			'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
			'counselplain' => '',
			'counseldef' => '',
			'court' => 'Kolkata',
			'court_type' => 'PC',
			'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
			'deposition' => '',
			'favorof' => null,
			'findings' => null,
			'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
			'judgement' => '<p style="text-align: justify;">Maclean, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p style="text-align: justify;">2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p style="text-align: justify;">3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Mitter, J.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p style="text-align: justify;">[1] </p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p style="text-align: justify;">order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p style="text-align: justify;">Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p style="text-align: justify;"> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p style="text-align: justify;">Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p style="text-align: justify;">that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p style="text-align: justify;">trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p style="text-align: justify;">records its findingh.<p style="text-align: justify;"></p><p style="text-align: justify;">',
			'observations' => null,
			'overruledby' => null,
			'prhistory' => '',
			'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
			'ratiodecidendi' => '',
			'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
			'sub' => 'Criminal',
			'link' => null,
			'circuit' => null
		)
	),
	'casename_url' => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr',
	'args' => array(
		(int) 0 => '874579',
		(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
	)
)
$title_for_layout = 'The Empress Vs Mohim Chunder Rai and anr - Citation 874579 - Court Judgment | '
$desc = array(
	'Judgement' => array(
		'id' => '874579',
		'acts' => '',
		'appealno' => '',
		'appellant' => 'The Empress',
		'authreffered' => '',
		'casename' => 'The Empress Vs. Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'casenote' => 'Assessors - Trial by Jury of a case properly triable with Assessors--Appeal on facts--Act VIII of 1871, Section 80--Criminal Procedure Code (Act X of 1872), Section 233. - ',
		'caseanalysis' => null,
		'casesref' => '',
		'citingcases' => '[1] 
  Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any
                          particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be
Local Government may      by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from
order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under
Session to be by jury.    this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such
                          Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.

Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on
that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the 
trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court 
records its findingh.',
		'counselplain' => '',
		'counseldef' => '',
		'court' => 'Kolkata',
		'court_type' => 'PC',
		'decidedon' => '1878-05-10',
		'deposition' => '',
		'favorof' => null,
		'findings' => null,
		'judge' => 'R.C. Mitter and ;Maclean, JJ.',
		'judgement' => '<p>Maclean, J.</p><p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).</p><p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal</p><p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.</p><p>Mitter, J.</p><p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.</p><p>[1] </p><p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any</p><p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be</p><p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from</p><p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under</p><p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such</p><p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on</p><p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the </p><p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court </p><p>records its findingh.<p></p><p>',
		'observations' => null,
		'overruledby' => null,
		'prhistory' => '',
		'pubs' => '(1878)ILR3Cal765',
		'ratiodecidendi' => '',
		'respondent' => 'Mohim Chunder Rai and anr.',
		'sub' => 'Criminal',
		'link' => null,
		'circuit' => null
	)
)
$casename_url = 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$args = array(
	(int) 0 => '874579',
	(int) 1 => 'empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
)
$url = 'https://sooperkanoon.com/case/amp/874579/empress-vs-mohim-chunder-rai-anr'
$ctype = ''
$content = array(
	(int) 0 => '<p>Maclean, J.',
	(int) 1 => '<p>1. The appellants have been convicted by the Sessions Court of the 24-Pargannas of an offence under the Registration Act, VIII of 1871, and as the trial was held with a jury, the petition of appeal filed on 13th April was directed to show certain errors of law, such as defects in the Judge's charge to the jury. By a subsequent petition of 17th April, the prisoners claim to be heard against the conviction on questions of fact as well as law, as the offence of which they have been convicted is not one of those to which trial by jury has been made applicable by the Government notification of January 1862 (Calcutta Gazette, 8th January 1862, p. 87).',
	(int) 2 => '<p>2. It has been contended before us by the Government Pleader that the Sessions Judge was competent to try the prisoners with a jury notwithstanding that the offence charged is not included in the Government notification referred to, and therefore the prisoners are not entitled to appeal against their conviction except upon matter of law; but it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to decide that question. The trial by a jury of an offence triable with assessors is not invalid on that ground Section 233, Criminal Procedure Code--Explanation)[1]; but it appears to me that the prisoners, who would have been entitled to an appeal on the facts, if the case had been tried with assessors, are not debarred from that merely by the fact that their trial by jury is not invalid. An error of procedure not affecting the merits of the case ought not to affect the prisoner's right of appeal',
	(int) 3 => '<p>3. Dealing, however, with this appeal as an appeal upon the facts, I consider the conviction of the prisoners a proper one, and I would dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 4 => '<p>Mitter, J.',
	(int) 5 => '<p>4. I concur; but I do not desire to express any opinion as to whether the prisoners are entitled to appeal on questions of fact. But assuming that they have this right, I concur with my learned colleague that the conviction of the prisoners is fully supported by the evidence. We accordingly dismiss the appeal.',
	(int) 6 => '<p>[1] ',
	(int) 7 => '<p> Section 233: The Local Government may order that the trial of all offences, or of any',
	(int) 8 => '<p> particular class of offences, before any Court of Session, shall be',
	(int) 9 => '<p>Local Government may by jury, in any district and such Local Government may from',
	(int) 10 => '<p>order trials before Court of time to time revoke or alter such order. Orders passed under',
	(int) 11 => '<p>Session to be by jury. this section shall be published in Official Gazette and in such',
	(int) 12 => '<p> Other manner as the Local Government from time to time' direct.<p>Explanation. If an offence triable with assessors is tried by a jury, the trial shall not on',
	(int) 13 => '<p>that ground merely be invailid. If an offence triable by a jury is tried with assessors, the ',
	(int) 14 => '<p>trial shall not on that ground merely be invalid, unless objection be taken before the Court ',
	(int) 15 => '<p>records its findingh.<p>',
	(int) 16 => '<p>'
)
$paragraphAfter = (int) 1
$cnt = (int) 17
$i = (int) 16
include - APP/View/Case/amp.ctp, line 144
View::_evaluate() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 971
View::_render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 933
View::render() - CORE/Cake/View/View.php, line 473
Controller::render() - CORE/Cake/Controller/Controller.php, line 963
Dispatcher::_invoke() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 200
Dispatcher::dispatch() - CORE/Cake/Routing/Dispatcher.php, line 167
[main] - APP/webroot/index.php, line 109