Fiitjee Ltd. Vs. Cce - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/46218
SubjectService Tax
CourtCustoms Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal CESTAT Delhi
Decided OnSep-26-2007
JudgeR Abichandani
Reported in(2008)12STJ71CESTATNew(Delhi)
AppellantFiitjee Ltd.
RespondentCce
Excerpt:
1. after hearing both sides and going through the relevant material on record, it appears that, prima-facie the adjudicating authority has not imposed penalty because at the time when the service was paid, the rate applicable was 8%. the fees for coaching services were charged in advance by the appellant. having regard to the nature of taxable service and, the fact that the total amount chargeable for the academic period was taken in advance, and service tax was paid on that amount, the appellant could not have contemplated an increase in the rate of tax at that time. therefore, there shall be waiver of pre-deposit of the amount of penalty payable under the impugned order, during the pendency of this appeal.2. the application stands disposed of accordingly. the appeal will now come ud for final hearing in its due course.
Judgment:
1. After hearing both sides and going through the relevant material on record, it appears that, prima-facie the adjudicating authority has not imposed penalty because at the time when the service was paid, the rate applicable was 8%. The fees for coaching services were charged in advance by the appellant. Having regard to the nature of taxable service and, the fact that the total amount chargeable for the academic period was taken in advance, and service tax was paid on that amount, the appellant could not have contemplated an increase in the rate of tax at that time. Therefore, there shall be waiver of pre-deposit of the amount of penalty payable under the impugned order, during the pendency of this appeal.

2. The application stands disposed of accordingly. The appeal will now come UD for final hearing in its due course.