State of West Bengal and ors Vs. Acc Ltd. and anr. - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/1097525
CourtKolkata High Court
Decided OnNov-12-2013
JudgeBANERJEE
AppellantState of West Bengal and ors
RespondentAcc Ltd. and anr.
Excerpt:
order sheet in the high court at calcutta civil appellate jurisdiction original side ga no.2731 of 2013 apot no.337 of 2013 wp no.509 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus acc ltd.& anr. ga no.2185 of 2013 apot no.337 of 2013 wp no.509 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus acci ltd.& anr. ga no.2186 of 2013 apot no.338 of 2013 wp no.464 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus bharti airtel ltd.ga no.2187 of 2013 apot no.339 of 2013 wp no.562 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus godrej consumer products ltd.ga no.2713 of 2013 apot no.436 of 2013 wp no.629 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus nokia india pvt.ltd.ga no.2716 of 2013 apot no.437 of 2013 wp no.567 of 2012 senior joint commissioner, sales tax & ors versus u.a.l.industries ltd.& anr. ga no.2720 of 2013 apot no.438 of 2013 wp no.624 of 2012 state of west bengal & anr versus glaxo smithkline consumer healthcare ltd.ga no.2719 of 2013 apot no.439 of 2013 wp no.627 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus marico ltd.ga no.2723 of 2013 apot no.440 of 2013 wp no.673 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus rohit ferrotech ltd.& anr. ga no.2724 of 2013 apot no.441 of 2013 wp no.619 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus philips carbon black ltd.& anr. ga no.2727 of 2013 apot no.442 of 2013 wp no.649 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus dutch tech tools pvt.ltd.ga no.2732 of 2013 apot no.443 of 2013 wp no.646 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus ambuj.cements ltd.& anr. ga no.2729 of 2013 apot no.444 of 2013 wp no.621 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus ranbaxy laboratories ltd.ga no.2736 of 2013 apot no.445 of 2013 wp no.674 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus impex ferrotech ltd.& anr. ga no.2734 of 2013 apot no.446 of 2013 wp no.675 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus impex metal and ferro alloys ltd.& anr. ga no.2738 of 2013 apot no.447 of 2013 wp no.659 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus vodafone east ltd.& anr. ga no.2744 of 2013 apot no.448 of 2013 wp no.695 of 2012 joint commissioner, commercial tax, group i, barrackpur & ors.versus century extrusions ltd.& anr. ga no.2741 of 2013 apot no.449 of 2013 wp no.595 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus pepsico india holdings pvt.ltd.ga no.2742 of 2013 apot no.450 of 2013 wp no.465 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus bharti telemedia ltd.ga no.2746 of 2013 apot no.451 of 2013 wp no.615 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus tata teleservices ltd.ga no.2748 of 2013 apot no.452 of 2013 wp no.628 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus cadbury india ltd.ga no.2750 of 2013 apot no.453 of 2013 wp no.682 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus siemens ltd.& anr. ga no.2752 of 2013 apot no.454 of 2013 wp no.565 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus whirlpool of india ltd.ga no.2755 of 2013 apot no.455 of 2013 wp no.688 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus eveready industries india ltd.ga no.2757 of 2013 apot no.456 of 2013 wp no.662 of 2012 state of west bengal & ors versus vodafone south ltd.& anr. ga no.2760 of 2013 apot no.457 of 2013 wp no.648 of 2012 state of west bengal & anr. versus wacker metroark chemicals pvt.ltd.& anr. before: the hon'ble justice banerjee,acting chief justice, the hon'ble justice debangsu basak date : 12th november, 2013. the court :- we intend to release these matters on the personal ground of one of us (banerjee, acting chief justice).at this juncture, learned counsel appearing for the parties would jointly pray, let these matters appear in the monthly list of january, 2014 anticipating change of constitution of the bench. accordingly, let these matters appear monthly list of january, 2014. (banerjee,acting chief justice j.) (debangsu basak, j.) dg/ in the
Judgment:

ORDER

SHEET IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA Civil Appellate Jurisdiction ORIGINAL SIDE GA No.2731 of 2013 APOT No.337 of 2013 WP No.509 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus ACC LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2185 of 2013 APOT No.337 of 2013 WP No.509 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus ACCI LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2186 of 2013 APOT No.338 of 2013 WP No.464 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus BHARTI AIRTEL LTD.GA No.2187 of 2013 APOT No.339 of 2013 WP No.562 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus GODREJ CONSUMER PRODUCTS LTD.GA No.2713 of 2013 APOT No.436 of 2013 WP No.629 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus NOKIA INDIA PVT.LTD.GA No.2716 of 2013 APOT No.437 of 2013 WP No.567 of 2012 SENIOR JOINT COMMISSIONER, SALES TAX & ORS Versus U.A.L.INDUSTRIES LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2720 of 2013 APOT No.438 of 2013 WP No.624 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ANR Versus GLAXO SMITHKLINE CONSUMER HEALTHCARE LTD.GA No.2719 of 2013 APOT No.439 of 2013 WP No.627 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus MARICO LTD.GA No.2723 of 2013 APOT No.440 of 2013 WP No.673 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus ROHIT FERROTECH LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2724 of 2013 APOT No.441 of 2013 WP No.619 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus PHILIPS CARBON BLACK LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2727 of 2013 APOT No.442 of 2013 WP No.649 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus DUTCH TECH TOOLS PVT.LTD.GA No.2732 of 2013 APOT No.443 of 2013 WP No.646 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus AMBUJ.CEMENTS LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2729 of 2013 APOT No.444 of 2013 WP No.621 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus RANBAXY LABORATORIES LTD.GA No.2736 of 2013 APOT No.445 of 2013 WP No.674 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus IMPEX FERROTECH LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2734 of 2013 APOT No.446 of 2013 WP No.675 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus IMPEX METAL AND FERRO ALLOYS LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2738 of 2013 APOT No.447 of 2013 WP No.659 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus VODAFONE EAST LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2744 of 2013 APOT No.448 of 2013 WP No.695 of 2012 JOINT COMMISSIONER, COMMERCIAL TAX, GROUP I, BARRACKPUR & ORS.Versus CENTURY EXTRUSIONS LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2741 of 2013 APOT No.449 of 2013 WP No.595 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus PEPSICO INDIA HOLDINGS PVT.LTD.GA No.2742 of 2013 APOT No.450 of 2013 WP No.465 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus BHARTI TELEMEDIA LTD.GA No.2746 of 2013 APOT No.451 of 2013 WP No.615 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus TATA TELESERVICES LTD.GA No.2748 of 2013 APOT No.452 of 2013 WP No.628 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus CADBURY INDIA LTD.GA No.2750 of 2013 APOT No.453 of 2013 WP No.682 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus SIEMENS LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2752 of 2013 APOT No.454 of 2013 WP No.565 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus WHIRLPOOL OF INDIA LTD.GA No.2755 of 2013 APOT No.455 of 2013 WP No.688 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus EVEREADY INDUSTRIES INDIA LTD.GA No.2757 of 2013 APOT No.456 of 2013 WP No.662 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Versus VODAFONE SOUTH LTD.& ANR.

GA No.2760 of 2013 APOT No.457 of 2013 WP No.648 of 2012 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ANR.

Versus WACKER METROARK CHEMICALS PVT.LTD.& ANR.

BEFORE: The Hon'ble JUSTICE BANERJEE,ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE, The Hon'ble JUSTICE DEBANGSU BASAK Date : 12th November, 2013.

The Court :- We intend to release these matters on the personal ground of one of us (Banerjee, Acting Chief Justice).At this juncture, learned Counsel appearing for the parties would jointly pray, let these matters appear in the monthly list of January, 2014 anticipating change of constitution of the Bench.

Accordingly, let these matters appear monthly list of January, 2014.

(BANERJEE,ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE J.) (DEBANGSU BASAK, J.) DG/ in the