State of W.B. and ors. Vs. Chhabi Roy (Som) - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/1059041
CourtKolkata High Court
Decided OnFeb-21-2013
JudgeBench
AppellantState of W.B. and ors.
RespondentChhabi Roy (Som)
Excerpt:
order sheet in the high court at calcutta civil appellate jurisdiction original side apo 46.of 200.with wp 101.of 2004 state of w.b.& ors.versus chhabi roy (som) apo 11.of 200.with wp 152.of 2002 state of w.b.& ors.versus sk. abdur rashid apo 12.of 2007 with wp 132.of 2002 state of w.b.& ors.versus sk. idris mohammed & ors.apo 12.of 2007 with wp 152.of 2002 state of w.b.& ors.versus md.abdul ghani & ors.apo 12.of 2007 with wp 140.of 2002 state of w.b.& ors.versus jaynal mullick apo 47.of 2007 with wp 142.of 2002 state of w.b.& ors.versus tayeb ali purkait apo 20.of 2008 with wp 190.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus anil kumar ghosh & ors.apo 20.of 2008 with wp 210.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus anil kumar roy & ors.apo 20.of 2008 with wp 192.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus sultan salauddin sarkar & ors.apo 21.of 2008 with wp 203.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus nanda kishore das & ors.apo 21.of 2008 with wp 203.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus narayan chandra modak & ors.apo 21.of 2008 with wp 189.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus nirmal kumar ghosh & ors.apo 21.of 2008 with wp 190.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus gopal das ghosh & ors.apo 23.of 2008 with wp 204.of 2002 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus dipali chatterjee & anr. apo 27.of 2008 with wp 243.of 2003 state of west bengal & ors.versus ananta kumar bhunia apo 29.of 2008 with wp 156.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal versus lakshmi kanta das & ors.& ors.apo 29.of 2008 with wp 216.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus rosayed ali mullick & ors.apo 30.of 2008 with wp 168.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus swapan kumar samanta & ors.apo 30.of 2008 with wp 216.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus tapan kumar maity & ors.apo 30.of 2008 with wp 168.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus kanti ranjan samanta & ors.apo 30.of 2008 with wp 171.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus subhash chandra maity & ors.apo 30.of 2008 with wp 221.of 2005 director of school education & ors.versus debasis chakraborty & ors.apo 30.of 2008 with wp 221.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus ramendra nath kanrar & ors.apo 9.of 2009 with wp 78.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus jitendra nath chatterjee & ors.apo 9.of 2009 with wp 69.of 2008 district inspector of schools (se).kolkata & anr. versus abhijit baidya & ors.apo 9.of 2009 with wp 5.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus gopal majumdar & ors.apo 9.of 2009 with wp 5.of 2005 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus rajib lochan sarkar & ors.apo 12.of 2009 with wp 52.of 2008 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus aswini kumar ghosal & ors.apo 12.of 2009 with wp 90.of 2008 the director of treasures & accounts, west bengal & ors.versus arun kumar mukherjee & ors.apo 12.of 2009 with wp 72.of 2008 director of school education, west bengal and ors.versus sujoy kumar datta & ors.apo 13.of 2009 with wp 90.of 2008 the director of treasuries & accounts, west bengal & ors.versus dulal chandra kar & ors.apo 13.of 2009 with wp 72.of 2008 director of treasuries& accounts, west bengal & ors.versus sunil kumar jana & ors.apo 2.of 2010 with wp 237.of 2003 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus md.enamul haque & ors.apo 2.of 2010 with wp 102.of 2004 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus faizuddin biswas & ors.apo 5.of 2010 with wp 49.of 2008 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus sunil kumar roy & ors.apo 5.of 2010 with wp 78.of 2008 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus shyamali ghosh (roy) & ors.apo 5.of 2010 with wp 61.of 2008 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus jagannath dutta & ors.apo 5.of 2010 with wp 65.of 2008 along with wp 94(w)/2008 fma 425/2005 fma 762/2008 fma 1552/2008 fma 1615/2008 fma 50/2009 director of school education, west bengal & ors.versus santi nath sil & ors.before: the hon'ble chief justice mr.arun mishra a n d the hon'ble justice dipankar datta a n d the hon'ble justice joymalya bagchi date :21. t february, 2013. mr.mr.mr.mr.mr.mr.bimal chatterjee, advocate general ashoke banerji, govt. pleader joytosh majumder, avratosh majumder, arindam mondal and sushovan sengupta, advocates …for appellants mr.bikash ranjan bhattacharyya, sr.advocate mr.s.s.arefin, mr.saktipada jana, mr.balailal sahoo, advocates mr.rabilal moitra, mr.ashim halder and mr.p.k.neogi, advocates ..for respondents (in item nos.28 to 32 & 36 to 38.) the court : mr.bhattacharyya, learned senior advocate on behalf of the respondents has prayed for time to file an application. prayer is allowed. let such application be filed by next monday, 25.02.2013, reply thereto be filed by the appellant on 27.02.2013. list this matter on next thursday,28.02.2013. urgent xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for be supplied to the parties subject to compliance with all requisite formalities. (joymalya bagchi,j.) (dipankar datta,j.(arun mishra,c.j.)
Judgment:

ORDER

SHEET IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA Civil Appellate Jurisdiction ORIGINAL SIDE APO 46.OF 200.WITH WP 101.of 2004 STATE OF W.B.& ORS.versus CHHABI ROY (SOM) APO 11.OF 200.WITH WP 152.of 2002 STATE OF W.B.& ORS.versus SK.

ABDUR RASHID APO 12.of 2007 WITH WP 132.of 2002 STATE OF W.B.& ORS.versus SK.

IDRIS MOHAMMED & ORS.APO 12.of 2007 WITH WP 152.of 2002 STATE OF W.B.& ORS.versus Md.ABDUL GHANI & ORS.APO 12.of 2007 WITH WP 140.of 2002 STATE OF W.B.& ORS.versus JAYNAL MULLICK APO 47.of 2007 WITH WP 142.of 2002 STATE OF W.B.& ORS.versus TAYEB ALI PURKAIT APO 20.of 2008 WITH WP 190.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus ANIL KUMAR GHOSH & ORS.APO 20.of 2008 WITH WP 210.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus ANIL KUMAR ROY & ORS.APO 20.of 2008 WITH WP 192.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SULTAN SALAUDDIN SARKAR & ORS.APO 21.of 2008 WITH WP 203.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus NANDA KISHORE DAS & ORS.APO 21.of 2008 WITH WP 203.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus NARAYAN CHANDRA MODAK & ORS.APO 21.of 2008 WITH WP 189.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus NIRMAL KUMAR GHOSH & ORS.APO 21.of 2008 WITH WP 190.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus GOPAL DAS GHOSH & ORS.APO 23.of 2008 WITH WP 204.of 2002 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus DIPALI CHATTERJEE & ANR.

APO 27.of 2008 WITH WP 243.of 2003 STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus ANANTA KUMAR BHUNIA APO 29.of 2008 WITH WP 156.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL versus LAKSHMI KANTA DAS & ORS.& ORS.APO 29.of 2008 WITH WP 216.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus ROSAYED ALI MULLICK & ORS.APO 30.of 2008 WITH WP 168.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SWAPAN KUMAR SAMANTA & ORS.APO 30.of 2008 WITH WP 216.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus TAPAN KUMAR MAITY & ORS.APO 30.of 2008 WITH WP 168.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus KANTI RANJAN SAMANTA & ORS.APO 30.of 2008 WITH WP 171.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SUBHASH CHANDRA MAITY & ORS.APO 30.of 2008 WITH WP 221.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION & ORS.versus DEBASIS CHAKRABORTY & ORS.APO 30.of 2008 WITH WP 221.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus RAMENDRA NATH KANRAR & ORS.APO 9.of 2009 WITH WP 78.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus JITENDRA NATH CHATTERJEE & ORS.APO 9.of 2009 WITH WP 69.of 2008 DISTRICT INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS (SE).KOLKATA & ANR.

versus ABHIJIT BAIDYA & ORS.APO 9.of 2009 WITH WP 5.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus GOPAL MAJUMDAR & ORS.APO 9.of 2009 WITH WP 5.of 2005 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus RAJIB LOCHAN SARKAR & ORS.APO 12.of 2009 WITH WP 52.of 2008 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus ASWINI KUMAR GHOSAL & ORS.APO 12.of 2009 WITH WP 90.of 2008 THE DIRECTOR OF TREASURES & ACCOUNTS, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus ARUN KUMAR MUKHERJEE & ORS.APO 12.of 2009 WITH WP 72.of 2008 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL AND ORS.versus SUJOY KUMAR DATTA & ORS.APO 13.of 2009 WITH WP 90.of 2008 THE DIRECTOR OF TREASURIES & ACCOUNTS, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus DULAL CHANDRA KAR & ORS.APO 13.of 2009 WITH WP 72.of 2008 DIRECTOR OF TREASURIES& ACCOUNTS, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SUNIL KUMAR JANA & ORS.APO 2.of 2010 WITH WP 237.of 2003 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus MD.ENAMUL HAQUE & ORS.APO 2.of 2010 WITH WP 102.of 2004 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus FAIZUDDIN BISWAS & ORS.APO 5.of 2010 WITH WP 49.of 2008 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SUNIL KUMAR ROY & ORS.APO 5.of 2010 WITH WP 78.of 2008 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SHYAMALI GHOSH (ROY) & ORS.APO 5.of 2010 WITH WP 61.of 2008 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus JAGANNATH DUTTA & ORS.APO 5.of 2010 WITH WP 65.of 2008 ALONG WITH WP 94(W)/2008 FMA 425/2005 FMA 762/2008 FMA 1552/2008 FMA 1615/2008 FMA 50/2009 DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, WEST BENGAL & ORS.versus SANTI NATH SIL & ORS.BEFORE: The Hon'ble CHIEF JUSTICE Mr.ARUN MISHRA A N D The Hon'ble JUSTICE DIPANKAR DATTA A N D The Hon'ble JUSTICE JOYMALYA BAGCHI Date :

21. t February, 2013.

Mr.Mr.Mr.Mr.Mr.Mr.Bimal Chatterjee, Advocate General Ashoke Banerji, Govt.

Pleader Joytosh Majumder, Avratosh Majumder, Arindam Mondal and Sushovan Sengupta, Advocates …for appellants Mr.Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya, Sr.Advocate Mr.S.S.Arefin, Mr.Saktipada Jana, Mr.Balailal Sahoo, Advocates Mr.Rabilal Moitra, Mr.Ashim Halder and Mr.P.K.Neogi, Advocates ..for respondents (in item nos.28 to 32 & 36 to 38.) The Court : Mr.Bhattacharyya, learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the respondents has prayed for time to file an application.

Prayer is allowed.

Let such application be filed by next Monday, 25.02.2013, reply thereto be filed by the appellant on 27.02.2013.

List this matter on next Thursday,28.02.2013.

Urgent xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for be supplied to the parties subject to compliance with all requisite formalities.

(JOYMALYA BAGCHI,J.) (DIPANKAR DATTA,J.(ARUN MISHRA,C.J.)