Ku. Pragya Bilgayan Vs. Board of Secondary Education - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/1045120
CourtMadhya Pradesh High Court
Decided OnDec-13-2012
AppellantKu. Pragya Bilgayan
RespondentBoard of Secondary Education
Excerpt:
w.p.no.13649/2012 (ku. pragya bilgayan versus board of secondary education) 13.12.2012 shri dinesh upadhyay, learned counsel for the petitioner. shri s.m.lal, learned govt. advocate, for the state. shri s. dharmadhikari, learned counsel for respondent board. the petitioner has filed this petition being aggrieved by the valuation of her answer sheets in the subjects of english (special).hindi (general) and mathematics in the higher secondary school certificate examination conducted by the respondent board in the year 2012. it was submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner had been awarded less marks in the subjects of english (special).hindi (general) and in mathematics, in which she has been awarded 70 marks in english, 93 marks in hindi and 61 in mathematics. the petitioner has alleged that his answer sheets have not been properly evaluated. in view of the aforesaid allegations, this court had directed the respondent board to produce the answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of english (special).hindi (general) and mathematics and had also directed the state to ensure the presence of two subject experts in each subject to revaluate the answer sheets of the petitioner. as directed by this court, the answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of mathematics has been produced by the respondent board and shri ramesh w.p.no.13649/2012 (ku. pragya bilgayan versus board of secondary education) kumar tripathi, tgt maths and shri satish kumar upadhaya, udt, maths of pandit lajja shanker jha, govt. school of excellence, jabalpur are present in person who are requested to assist in the revaluation of the petitioner's answer sheets. both the subject experts, after separately revaluating the answer sheets of the petitioner have given an opinion that there is no change in the marks awarded by the original examiners in the subject of mathematics. the answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of hindi (general) has been produced by the respondent board and mrs.richa vyas, sr.lecturer- hindi of pandit lajja shanker jha, govt. school of excellence, jabalpur and mrs.manjula kujur, p.g.t.hindi of kendriya vidyalaya no.1, gcf, jabalpur are present in person who are requested to assist in the revaluation of the petitioner's answer sheets. both the subject experts, after separately revaluating the answer sheets of the petitioner have given an opinion that there is no change in the marks awarded by the original examiners in the subject of hindi(general).the answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of english (special) has been produced by the respondent board and mrs.dorothy paul, lecturer- general english/special english of pandit lajja shanker jha, govt. school of excellence, jabalpur and mrs.b.mukherjee, lecturer – english of kendriya vidyalaya no.1, gcf, jabalpur are present in person who are requested to assist w.p.no.13649/2012 (ku. pragya bilgayan versus board of secondary education) in the revaluation of the petitioner's answer sheets. both the subject experts, after separately revaluating the answer sheets of the petitioner have given an opinion that at best there could be a change of two marks, which does not warrant any change in the result in the subject of english (special).in view of the aforesaid, after revaluation of the copies of the petitioner by two subject experts each in this court in the subjects of mathematics, hindi and english, as no change is found, therefore, in view of the undertaking given by the petitioner, she is directed to deposit rs.5,000/- with the high court legal services authority as well as pay the cost of rs.500/- towards revaluation to each of the teachers present in the court and rs.100/- each towards transportation charges. in view of the aforesaid, the petition filed by the petitioner stands dismissed. (r.s.jha) judge gn
Judgment:

W.P.No.13649/2012 (Ku.

Pragya Bilgayan versus Board of Secondary Education) 13.12.2012 Shri Dinesh Upadhyay, learned counsel for the petitioner.

Shri S.M.Lal, learned Govt.

Advocate, for the State.

Shri S.

Dharmadhikari, learned counsel for respondent Board.

The petitioner has filed this petition being aggrieved by the valuation of her answer sheets in the subjects of English (Special).Hindi (General) and Mathematics in the Higher Secondary School Certificate Examination conducted by the respondent Board in the year 2012.

It was submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner had been awarded less marks in the subjects of English (Special).Hindi (General) and in Mathematics, in which she has been awarded 70 marks in English, 93 marks in Hindi and 61 in Mathematics.

The petitioner has alleged that his answer sheets have not been properly evaluated.

In view of the aforesaid allegations, this Court had directed the respondent Board to produce the answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of English (Special).Hindi (General) and Mathematics and had also directed the State to ensure the presence of two subject experts in each subject to revaluate the answer sheets of the petitioner.

As directed by this Court, the answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of Mathematics has been produced by the respondent Board and Shri Ramesh W.P.No.13649/2012 (Ku.

Pragya Bilgayan versus Board of Secondary Education) Kumar Tripathi, TGT Maths and Shri Satish Kumar Upadhaya, UDT, Maths of Pandit Lajja Shanker Jha, Govt.

School of Excellence, Jabalpur are present in person who are requested to assist in the revaluation of the petitioner's answer sheets.

Both the subject experts, after separately revaluating the answer sheets of the petitioner have given an opinion that there is no change in the marks awarded by the original examiners in the subject of Mathematics.

The answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of Hindi (General) has been produced by the respondent Board and MRS.Richa Vyas, Sr.Lecturer- Hindi of Pandit Lajja Shanker Jha, Govt.

School of Excellence, Jabalpur and MRS.Manjula Kujur, P.G.T.Hindi of Kendriya Vidyalaya No.1, GCF, Jabalpur are present in person who are requested to assist in the revaluation of the petitioner's answer sheets.

Both the subject experts, after separately revaluating the answer sheets of the petitioner have given an opinion that there is no change in the marks awarded by the original examiners in the subject of Hindi(General).The answer sheets of the petitioner in the subject of English (Special) has been produced by the respondent Board and MRS.Dorothy Paul, Lecturer- General English/Special English of Pandit Lajja Shanker Jha, Govt.

School of Excellence, Jabalpur and Mrs.B.Mukherjee, Lecturer – English of Kendriya Vidyalaya No.1, GCF, Jabalpur are present in person who are requested to assist W.P.No.13649/2012 (Ku.

Pragya Bilgayan versus Board of Secondary Education) in the revaluation of the petitioner's answer sheets.

Both the subject experts, after separately revaluating the answer sheets of the petitioner have given an opinion that at best there could be a change of two marks, which does not warrant any change in the result in the subject of English (Special).In view of the aforesaid, after revaluation of the copies of the petitioner by two subject experts each in this court in the subjects of Mathematics, Hindi and English, as no change is found, therefore, in view of the undertaking given by the petitioner, she is directed to deposit Rs.5,000/- with the High Court Legal Services Authority as well as pay the cost of Rs.500/- towards revaluation to each of the teachers present in the Court and Rs.100/- each towards transportation charges.

In view of the aforesaid, the petition filed by the petitioner stands dismissed.

(R.S.Jha) Judge gn