Usha Devi Vs. Gopinathan - Court Judgment

SooperKanoon Citationsooperkanoon.com/1013634
SubjectLand Acquisition
CourtKerala High Court
Decided OnFeb-04-2013
JudgeHonourable Mr.Justice Thomas P.Joseph
AppellantUsha Devi
RespondentGopinathan
Excerpt:
in the high court of kerala at ernakulam present: the honourable mr.justice thomas p.joseph monday, the 4th day of february 2013 15th magha 193 op(c).no. 183 of 2013 (o) ------------------------- ia.no.6555/2010 in os no.661/2003 of principal sub court,thrissur petitioner(s): -------------------------- usha devi d/o. late m. bhasakara menon, flat no. 2d, c-block chakkolas, willingdon enclave, chakkolas habitat thevara ferry road, kochi-682013. by advs.sri.s.vinod bhat sri.legith t.kottakkal respondent(s): ---------------------------- 1. gopinathan gopinivas, s/o. mannath bhaskara menon kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk palliyil lane, kottappuram road, thrissur-680004.2. vijayakumar s/o. mannath bhaskara menon, kottappuram desom thrissur village and taluk, palliyl lane kottappuram road, thrissur-680004.3. thankamma alias padmaja d/o. thekkumannath chinnamma, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.4. gopinatha menon s/o.thekkumannath chinnamma, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.5. raveendranatha menon s/o.thekkumannath chinnamma, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.6. santhakumara menon s/o.thekkumannath chinnamma, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.7. gopalakrishna menon s/o.thekkumannath chinnamma, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.8. pankaji a menon w/o. late achukuttan, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001. op(c) no.183/201”9. krishnanjali menon d/o. pankaji a menon, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.10. jyothilekshmi d/o. pankaji a menon, s/o. thekkemannath chinnamma naikkanal desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.11. parvathy devi d/o. thekkemannath kizhakkathil late parukutty naikkanal desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.12. jaya d/o. mannath thankam @ padmaja, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.13. maya d/o.mannath thankam @ padmaja, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.14. narayanan s/o. mannath thankam @ padmaja, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.15. muraleedharan s/o.mannath thankam @ padmaja, naikkanal desom thrissur village and taluk, thrissur-680001.16. muhammed bhasheer, s/o. abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house, kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.17. muhammed moosa s/o.abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house, kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.18. salam s/o.abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house, kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.19. ummer s/o.abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house, kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.20. abdul assees s/o.abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur-680001.21. shajahan s/o.abdul rahiman, povathparambil house kottappuram desom, thrissur village and taluk thrissur 68 001. op(c) no.183/201”22. noushad s/o.abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house kottappuram desom, thrissur vilalge and taluk thrissur 68 001.23. sakir hussain s/o.abdul rahiman, pouvathparambil house kottappuram desom, thrissur vilalge and taluk thrissur 68 001.24. radhakrishnan tc 35/1122, s/o.ponnuswami chettiyar, naikkanal desom thrissur 68 001.25. baburaj s/o.ponnuswami chettiyar, naikkanal desom thrissur 68 001.26. manikandan s/o.ponnuswami chettiyar, naikkanal desom thrissur 68 001.27. meenakshikutty (died) do.lakshmikutty amma, kumar nivas, thekkemuri amsom desom, ottapalam taluk, ottapalam 67 101.28. khadar s/o.panikkassery kadavil kunji hydrose edathirinji amsom, kodungallur taluk kodungallur 69
Judgment:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT: THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE THOMAS P.JOSEPH MONDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2013 15TH MAGHA 193 OP(C).No. 183 of 2013 (O) ------------------------- IA.NO.6555/2010 IN OS NO.661/2003 of PRINCIPAL SUB COURT,THRISSUR PETITIONER(S): -------------------------- USHA DEVI D/O. LATE M. BHASAKARA MENON, FLAT NO. 2D, C-BLOCK CHAKKOLAS, WILLINGDON ENCLAVE, CHAKKOLAS HABITAT THEVARA FERRY ROAD, KOCHI-682013. BY ADVS.SRI.S.VINOD BHAT SRI.LEGITH T.KOTTAKKAL RESPONDENT(S): ---------------------------- 1. GOPINATHAN GOPINIVAS, S/O. MANNATH BHASKARA MENON KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK PALLIYIL LANE, KOTTAPPURAM ROAD, THRISSUR-680004.

2. VIJAYAKUMAR S/O. MANNATH BHASKARA MENON, KOTTAPPURAM DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, PALLIYL LANE KOTTAPPURAM ROAD, THRISSUR-680004.

3. THANKAMMA ALIAS PADMAJA D/O. THEKKUMANNATH CHINNAMMA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

4. GOPINATHA MENON S/O.THEKKUMANNATH CHINNAMMA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

5. RAVEENDRANATHA MENON S/O.THEKKUMANNATH CHINNAMMA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

6. SANTHAKUMARA MENON S/O.THEKKUMANNATH CHINNAMMA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

7. GOPALAKRISHNA MENON S/O.THEKKUMANNATH CHINNAMMA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

8. PANKAJI A MENON W/O. LATE ACHUKUTTAN, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001. OP(C) NO.183/201”

9. KRISHNANJALI MENON D/O. PANKAJI A MENON, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

10. JYOTHILEKSHMI D/O. PANKAJI A MENON, S/O. THEKKEMANNATH CHINNAMMA NAIKKANAL DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

11. PARVATHY DEVI D/O. THEKKEMANNATH KIZHAKKATHIL LATE PARUKUTTY NAIKKANAL DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

12. JAYA D/O. MANNATH THANKAM @ PADMAJA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

13. MAYA D/O.MANNATH THANKAM @ PADMAJA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

14. NARAYANAN S/O. MANNATH THANKAM @ PADMAJA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

15. MURALEEDHARAN S/O.MANNATH THANKAM @ PADMAJA, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK, THRISSUR-680001.

16. MUHAMMED BHASHEER, S/O. ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE, KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

17. MUHAMMED MOOSA S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE, KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

18. SALAM S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE, KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

19. UMMER S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE, KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

20. ABDUL ASSEES S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR-680001.

21. SHAJAHAN S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILLAGE AND TALUK THRISSUR 68 001. OP(C) NO.183/201”

22. NOUSHAD S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILALGE AND TALUK THRISSUR 68 001.

23. SAKIR HUSSAIN S/O.ABDUL RAHIMAN, POUVATHPARAMBIL HOUSE KOTTAPPURAM DESOM, THRISSUR VILALGE AND TALUK THRISSUR 68 001.

24. RADHAKRISHNAN TC 35/1122, S/O.PONNUSWAMI CHETTIYAR, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR 68 001.

25. BABURAJ S/O.PONNUSWAMI CHETTIYAR, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR 68 001.

26. MANIKANDAN S/O.PONNUSWAMI CHETTIYAR, NAIKKANAL DESOM THRISSUR 68 001.

27. MEENAKSHIKUTTY (DIED) DO.LAKSHMIKUTTY AMMA, KUMAR NIVAS, THEKKEMURI AMSOM DESOM, OTTAPALAM TALUK, OTTAPALAM 67 101.

28. KHADAR S/O.PANIKKASSERY KADAVIL KUNJI HYDROSE EDATHIRINJI AMSOM, KODUNGALLUR TALUK KODUNGALLUR 69